Hello O scale world
York was great this April ... complete with a small bit of O scale scattered around . I was very fortunate to pick up two Icken pieces .
The electric box cab give new meaning to "heavy" ... complete with two motors ,should pull just about anything that is placed behind it . The sides on the motor car a fine castings with nice detail. Both examples still retain the outside 3rd rail pick ups. Looking forward to running both in the near future.
Cheers Carey
Fred Icken models
Re: Fred Icken models
Carey,
Looks like you hit the jackpot! They seem to be in excellent condition.
Rich
Looks like you hit the jackpot! They seem to be in excellent condition.
Rich
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3140
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Re: Fred Icken models
Carey, both Icken and Alexander sold the New Haven EY-3 boxcar. Your appears to be an Alexander version, which can be ascertained by the drive. The Alexander version is not common but not that rare either -- I have seen at least a dozen, owned by fellow modelers or otherwise sold on eBay. By comparison, I have never seen an Icken version other than in the catalog. Of course, if yours is marked Icken, that would be different.
And I agree with Rich, both of these are in very nice condition.
Jim
And I agree with Rich, both of these are in very nice condition.
Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size
-
stephen neill
- Posts: 151
- Joined: Thu Jun 23, 2016 6:16 pm
Re: Fred Icken models
Way to go Carey! Maybe I should start going to York. What other O scale did you see there?
Steve
Steve
-
Carey Williams
- Posts: 690
- Joined: Sat Dec 24, 2016 3:10 pm
Re: Fred Icken models
Hello all
Thank you for your kind words . Alexander used the same illustration of the cab in their 1937 catalog... I've found early Icken literature with chain drive listed ( as seen on Powered car) and later mention all gear drive . Were Icken and Alexander selling the same product ? ..Icken mentions the top reverse unit as is on this engine . Both pieces have the same 3 rd rail pick up shoe ... but no signs of Icken's name of box cab .
Attached photos ... a box cab working the Westchester Railway Club layout from August 1936 Model Railroading ...Alexander's old layout he donated to help form the club.
Also photo of Ed Alexander with his hand partially hiding a similar box cab.
And page from Icken catalog with one of the drive mech used ..from undated catalog at the TCA library.
There seems to have been a large layout / collection of older stuff that was broken up in NJ .... that found it's way to York in the hands of several dealers... many older freights ...( I'll post a few photos later of the ones I bought ) .. a number of steamers with out side 3rd rail and some with out ... pieces from the 50's ? and a few KMT with shoes added .... so old but not old enough ...
I flipped over every O scale car I could find searching for Egolf ... or any other early makers .. no luck on any Egolf pieces ..
Looking forward to York in the fall for more freight car flipping and the search for 3rd rail chairs ...( one small bag was found this meet!!!!) . Fortunately old O scale remains a relative bargain compared to many tinplate pieces .
Cheers Carey
Thank you for your kind words . Alexander used the same illustration of the cab in their 1937 catalog... I've found early Icken literature with chain drive listed ( as seen on Powered car) and later mention all gear drive . Were Icken and Alexander selling the same product ? ..Icken mentions the top reverse unit as is on this engine . Both pieces have the same 3 rd rail pick up shoe ... but no signs of Icken's name of box cab .
Attached photos ... a box cab working the Westchester Railway Club layout from August 1936 Model Railroading ...Alexander's old layout he donated to help form the club.
Also photo of Ed Alexander with his hand partially hiding a similar box cab.
And page from Icken catalog with one of the drive mech used ..from undated catalog at the TCA library.
There seems to have been a large layout / collection of older stuff that was broken up in NJ .... that found it's way to York in the hands of several dealers... many older freights ...( I'll post a few photos later of the ones I bought ) .. a number of steamers with out side 3rd rail and some with out ... pieces from the 50's ? and a few KMT with shoes added .... so old but not old enough ...
I flipped over every O scale car I could find searching for Egolf ... or any other early makers .. no luck on any Egolf pieces ..
Looking forward to York in the fall for more freight car flipping and the search for 3rd rail chairs ...( one small bag was found this meet!!!!) . Fortunately old O scale remains a relative bargain compared to many tinplate pieces .
Cheers Carey
-
stephen neill
- Posts: 151
- Joined: Thu Jun 23, 2016 6:16 pm
Re: Fred Icken models
Carey -
I have a catalog for The American Model Railroad Company (Alexander) that is not dated but says it is the seventh catalog. On page 13 of that catalog is a picture of a New Haven box cab; it certainly appears to be the same picture as you show above in the Icken catalog; not just the same engine, the same picture, and of course the engine number is the same.
It certainly appears that both Icken and Alexander were selling box cabs with the same body; I can not comment on the drives as I have not researched them; but from Jim's comment it seems that each developed their own drive for the engine.
I have another catalog for The American Model Railroad Company, undated, that says on the cover "THIS, the second edition of the first Scale Model Railroad catalog in America, has been ....". On the first page it says "We are agents for or can supply the goods of: Icken-Barker Models R. D. Barr ..."
Icken-Barker Models is the early name for Icken Model Company: the address shown is Oritan Avenue, Ridgefield, N. J.
Steve
I have a catalog for The American Model Railroad Company (Alexander) that is not dated but says it is the seventh catalog. On page 13 of that catalog is a picture of a New Haven box cab; it certainly appears to be the same picture as you show above in the Icken catalog; not just the same engine, the same picture, and of course the engine number is the same.
It certainly appears that both Icken and Alexander were selling box cabs with the same body; I can not comment on the drives as I have not researched them; but from Jim's comment it seems that each developed their own drive for the engine.
I have another catalog for The American Model Railroad Company, undated, that says on the cover "THIS, the second edition of the first Scale Model Railroad catalog in America, has been ....". On the first page it says "We are agents for or can supply the goods of: Icken-Barker Models R. D. Barr ..."
Icken-Barker Models is the early name for Icken Model Company: the address shown is Oritan Avenue, Ridgefield, N. J.
Steve
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13676
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Fred Icken models
I have the pair that used to belong to Watty House.
-
Carey Williams
- Posts: 690
- Joined: Sat Dec 24, 2016 3:10 pm
Re: Fred Icken models
Hello Icken fans
Fortuitous ad ....
Fortuitous ad ....
-
Carey Williams
- Posts: 690
- Joined: Sat Dec 24, 2016 3:10 pm
Re: Fred Icken models
Hello all
I've been having fun trying to get the bricks to move .....in anticipation of the Indy show .
Here is a link to see the Alexander box cab spring into action .
Come to Indy to see all the the action "live" .
Cheers Carey
https://ogrforum.ogaugerr.com/topic/ind ... 4404477603
I've been having fun trying to get the bricks to move .....in anticipation of the Indy show .
Here is a link to see the Alexander box cab spring into action .
Come to Indy to see all the the action "live" .
Cheers Carey
https://ogrforum.ogaugerr.com/topic/ind ... 4404477603
-
1wrenchturner
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Mon Feb 12, 2018 3:36 pm
Re: Fred Icken models
HI Carey,
I have two of the Icken boxcabs brand new and unbuilt. There are no motors, just the raw castings with bronze pantographs as well. It also seems that there are at least two versions of the Icken boxcab. I have a catalogue that has one picture then there are your photos and my castings. Both different. Any help with that? Did they change castings somewhere along the line? Can you shed some light? Let me know.
Thanks
I have two of the Icken boxcabs brand new and unbuilt. There are no motors, just the raw castings with bronze pantographs as well. It also seems that there are at least two versions of the Icken boxcab. I have a catalogue that has one picture then there are your photos and my castings. Both different. Any help with that? Did they change castings somewhere along the line? Can you shed some light? Let me know.
Thanks
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 39 guests