This is all subjective, just like headlights. Yes, for me it is visually worse on Lionel - especially the Hudson and 701 switcher. First thing I did to those two was scale flanges on all drivers.
I have not seen blind driers on Proto-48. I suspect they would be lots less objectionable to my.eye.
Scale Craft Mountain
-
steamaheadstephen59
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2021 7:23 pm
Re: Scale Craft Mountain
Its true the larger the flanges the more the blind drivers stick out. They don't show much on the real thing. I feel lately I don't have time to be overly critical on a model, so Im letting some things go!
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13676
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Scale Craft Mountain
Don’t hesitate! Trainz has a slightly damaged Scale Craft Mountain with incorrect tender trucks for the low, low price of $1500 on eBay right now. It does appear to have flanges on all drivers.
Re: Scale Craft Mountain
bob turner wrote:Don’t hesitate! Trainz has a slightly damaged Scale Craft Mountain with incorrect tender trucks for the low, low price of $1500 on eBay right now. It does appear to have flanges on all drivers.
My finger is twitching....................Naaaaaaaaaaaaah!
Just thinking that it wasn't all that long ago you could have bought a Sunset/3rd rail PRR M1a new for a grand.
Re: Scale Craft Mountain
steamaheadstephen59 wrote:Its true the larger the flanges the more the blind drivers stick out. They don't show much on the real thing. I feel lately I don't have time to be overly critical on a model, so Im letting some things go!
It's YOUR stuff, and all of it is subjective, so if YOU like it, that's really all that matters. Don't take too much stock in what is really just opinion! Sometimes what is less aesthetically pleasing is superior function wise, a point being the pilot truck on Pacifics. I have always preferred the look of a single axle up front, but dual axles track better (so THEY say). What do THEY know!
Rich
Re: Scale Craft Mountain
bob turner wrote:I have not seen blind driers on Proto-48. I suspect they would be lots less objectionable to my.eye.
Find someone who does PRR in P48 and has a correct Decapod. The early version had the 2,3,4 drivers blind, later to be changed to only the number 3 blind.
As I recall, the US Hobbies had 3 blind, and the Sunset 1.
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13676
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Scale Craft Mountain
I was looking for my ATSF "convertible" thread - I think I posted photos of the Scale Craft Mikado, then my 2-10-2, my 4-8-2, and finally a really inaccurate 4-6-2 with Box Pok drivers (this last one has become a Katy Pacific, since both Katy and T&P had Box Pok Pacifics.
But I found this from a year and a half ago - so you do not get to see all the variants again.
Maroon sent me another S/C boiler a couple months ago, and so I set out to make a more or less permanent ATSF Mountain. It will get its own tender, pretty much to match the builder's photo of #3700. Not sure if I will paint the rods yellow, but otherwise I am copying the photo found in p.295 of the Worley book. I note that photos of Santa Fe power indicate that several boiler tapers were used both on 2-10-2s and 4-8-2s - and since the Scale Craft casting has at best a minimal taper, I choose my prototypes carefully.
Herewith:


Oh - PS- once a few more responses come in to Dave's "Shark" thread I will repost my doorstop Shark. I am sure Jim will add - he has some Sharks!
But I found this from a year and a half ago - so you do not get to see all the variants again.
Maroon sent me another S/C boiler a couple months ago, and so I set out to make a more or less permanent ATSF Mountain. It will get its own tender, pretty much to match the builder's photo of #3700. Not sure if I will paint the rods yellow, but otherwise I am copying the photo found in p.295 of the Worley book. I note that photos of Santa Fe power indicate that several boiler tapers were used both on 2-10-2s and 4-8-2s - and since the Scale Craft casting has at best a minimal taper, I choose my prototypes carefully.
Herewith:
Oh - PS- once a few more responses come in to Dave's "Shark" thread I will repost my doorstop Shark. I am sure Jim will add - he has some Sharks!
Re: Scale Craft Mountain
Bob, finelooking machine!
Dan Weinhold
Dan Weinhold
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13676
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Scale Craft Mountain
No - Lobaugh Berk tender with the top straightened, and the body widened. It goes behind my Katy Pacific. I will be building a proper ATSF tender - it is larger than this, but small relative to the huge 4-8-4 tenders I am using behind the Mike and 2-10-2. Here is a repeat photo:

Note that this is a different boiler - it used to go back and forth between the 2-10-2 and the 4-8-2, but now, thanks to Maroon, I have two extended boilers. Note the relative lack of details and running boards on the new boiler.
That is a scratchbuilt tender on MG trucks. I also have an identical MG tender behind the Mike, and an extra ATSF Mike tender with Pullman trucks. I always have spare tenders!
I had Burlington decals left over from the Seacrest days. Callie Graphics will make Katy "stick-ons."
Note that this is a different boiler - it used to go back and forth between the 2-10-2 and the 4-8-2, but now, thanks to Maroon, I have two extended boilers. Note the relative lack of details and running boards on the new boiler.
That is a scratchbuilt tender on MG trucks. I also have an identical MG tender behind the Mike, and an extra ATSF Mike tender with Pullman trucks. I always have spare tenders!
I had Burlington decals left over from the Seacrest days. Callie Graphics will make Katy "stick-ons."
-
steamaheadstephen59
- Posts: 238
- Joined: Wed Sep 01, 2021 7:23 pm
Re: Scale Craft Mountain
I love what you have don with the scale craft mick boilers they both look great to me. Bob didn’t you do a build artical in 1/48 on building the SP tender for the mountain?
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 47 guests