
This one is a quad, and presence of the fine rivets identifies it as a Min-I-Scale model. I like these but they are 17/64s and weigh over two pounds, which I find at or beyond the limits for an operating railroad (at least one that runs long trains, as is my want).
As to whether this finish is appropriate is debatable, but here is my two-cents worth: I preserve original finishes when I can do so without undo effort. However, if a car must be refinished then it's "modeler's choice". I do sniff when a model is obviously to old or new for a particular road name or operating scenario, but (without doing any research), I would take even odds that BN had quad hoppers (and probably a LOT of them). However, I wouldn't choose BN mainly because I don't generally model that era. This brings up a good question regarding this GN hopper and its three brothers: Who is (or was) the O-scale modeler that modeled the BN era that was willing to lug around four cars that together weigh about nine pounds? Were they going to pull them with their Atlas BN F9?












