NOT model railroad related. Proper warning has been issued!
I have been dealing for weeks with a machinist. Known him for years, usually really good.
He's got a 48 Ford flathead V-8 in his shop for rebuild. I know more about these things than just about anyone left locally (KOOK- Keeper Of Obscure Knowledge).
48 and earlier had full floating rod bearings, 40PSI oil pump....I provided him with a 49-53 crank, full set of rods for use with Clevite bearings....and he's confused. I even drove out there this morning. He can't get the oil pump and screen to fit.
Has a 36-42 pump with integral screen, wore out. Replacement pumps are for 49-53, 60PSI. I took a 5 gallon bucket of pickups and screens, sorted that.....and the sump he's gonna use (oil pan) won't fit. Came off a donor motor he picked up, no idea why, had a transverse baffle. Old pan has no baffle, so cut the baffle out, right?
Why does one have a baffle and one doesn't? Do I really want to cut it out?
Got home, the calls and e-mails started in....aluminum rear main seal holders are not square cross section slot to accept a rope seal, rather narrow and tapered on one side.
Has a replacement crank, all done, one slinger (actually rear thrust), had him dig out the crank that was in his customer's engine when delivered. TWO slingers.
Okay, you have a 36-42 crank, NO rope seals, just a slinger.
How do we know that?
Take a tape measure, measure from a known spot on center main back to centerline of aluminum housing.
Why? Can't I just measure from rear main?
Oh, you can, in limited space, not well lit...
Then measure from the same spot on the crank and compare the two measurements.
What do you mean? Can't be precise with a tape measure!
It's good enough for this to see if that rear slinger lines up with the aluminum housings.
Then more e-mails, put the instructions in print, then he JUST called, still confused. had to re-explain someone, somewhere put a 36-42 crank, oil pump, screen and slinger housings into a 48 block.
Even sent him links to find the correct aluminum parts to actually hold the rope seals.
He may have it now. Waiting on another call.......
I think I'll go have a stroke
aaaaarrrrrrrrrrrgggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
aaaaarrrrrrrrrrrgggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!
Dave....gone by invitation
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: aaaaarrrrrrrrrrrgggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!
Better than me. I went through so many 8BA blocks . . . All of them cracked center exhaust to cylinder. Convert to a 289?
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: aaaaarrrrrrrrrrrgggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!
Easy fix. Had many plugged, cast iron, clean up the bore and new seat, never moves.
The other one is an old customer, 50 Convert, ported and relieved, one crack, wants to find another block. The cost of repairing his block compared to finding another block, machining it to rebuild AND port/relieve is so far apart.
I saw the Merc crank from that today. No way is that an engine I did. I have no idea what someone was thinking on balancing, but they welded one throw up solid, filled all the factory balance holes, and on the other side used a bandsaw to cut one whole knob off, right down the the cast void in the crank. I would have refused to put that in. Stupid. Weakened the crank.
The other one is an old customer, 50 Convert, ported and relieved, one crack, wants to find another block. The cost of repairing his block compared to finding another block, machining it to rebuild AND port/relieve is so far apart.
I saw the Merc crank from that today. No way is that an engine I did. I have no idea what someone was thinking on balancing, but they welded one throw up solid, filled all the factory balance holes, and on the other side used a bandsaw to cut one whole knob off, right down the the cast void in the crank. I would have refused to put that in. Stupid. Weakened the crank.
Dave....gone by invitation
Re: aaaaarrrrrrrrrrrgggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!
ScaleCraft wrote:I think I'll go have a stroke
Maybe I can help hasten things along! How much is he going to charge you for working on your own car?
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: aaaaarrrrrrrrrrrgggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!
Oh, it's not my car! My cars run. This is a customer who contacted him, then he contacts me for parts and knowledge.
I did this for so long..when I did an engine, new parts came out, old parts went back in the boxes and on the shelf under the workbench. If I ever had any question on compatibility of new parts, the old ones were there. This is a new facility for him, and he just throws the old parts away when he removes them. Not good.
When I tear an engine own, I do as much forensic analysis as I can. Using an old beam-type torque wrench, I see how much torque to remove head bolts, main cap bolts, rod nuts. I then know if something was coming loose.
That's how I discovered the camshaft problem in my Jag when I pulled the engine, then head, for an externally leaking head gasket.
The two cams are infinitely adjustable. There is a notched tool fits into a notch at he rear of the cams. Inlet cam was 28 crank degrees advanced, exhaust retarded about 10. Curious.
I knew inlet lash was zero. Solid lifter,and zero. Ran okay. Car didn't have much power, but neither I nor anyone I knew had experience in 2.4L Jag engines
Head off, manifolds off, cams out, lifters with internal shims out on marked board.
Looking at the engine on the stand, siting on a stool in my garage, I pondered what the circular marks were on the pistons. They stick up quite a ways, hemi head and all that.
Cam advanced, inlet valves were hitting the pistons. The last clowns into it "fixed" it by zero-lashing inlet valves. And it wasn't enough.
Two bent valves, lapped them all in (good, lapped right in), did rings, bearings....if anyone is interested I'll go into rod nut cotter keys and oil pumps and bearings......and carbs, and distributor..trying to get power out of a kluge rebuild.
I did this for so long..when I did an engine, new parts came out, old parts went back in the boxes and on the shelf under the workbench. If I ever had any question on compatibility of new parts, the old ones were there. This is a new facility for him, and he just throws the old parts away when he removes them. Not good.
When I tear an engine own, I do as much forensic analysis as I can. Using an old beam-type torque wrench, I see how much torque to remove head bolts, main cap bolts, rod nuts. I then know if something was coming loose.
That's how I discovered the camshaft problem in my Jag when I pulled the engine, then head, for an externally leaking head gasket.
The two cams are infinitely adjustable. There is a notched tool fits into a notch at he rear of the cams. Inlet cam was 28 crank degrees advanced, exhaust retarded about 10. Curious.
I knew inlet lash was zero. Solid lifter,and zero. Ran okay. Car didn't have much power, but neither I nor anyone I knew had experience in 2.4L Jag engines
Head off, manifolds off, cams out, lifters with internal shims out on marked board.
Looking at the engine on the stand, siting on a stool in my garage, I pondered what the circular marks were on the pistons. They stick up quite a ways, hemi head and all that.
Cam advanced, inlet valves were hitting the pistons. The last clowns into it "fixed" it by zero-lashing inlet valves. And it wasn't enough.
Two bent valves, lapped them all in (good, lapped right in), did rings, bearings....if anyone is interested I'll go into rod nut cotter keys and oil pumps and bearings......and carbs, and distributor..trying to get power out of a kluge rebuild.
Dave....gone by invitation
Re: aaaaarrrrrrrrrrrgggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!
Sounds like you are a mechanic and he is a parts replacer. Guessing a lot of that goes on.
Or judging by the thread title a pirate.

Or judging by the thread title a pirate.
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: aaaaarrrrrrrrrrrgggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!
And it continues.
Couple of phone calls worth, finally a picture.
Why are there grooves out of the rear main seal housing in the main cap? Are they oil drains?
Most of my work is on 49-53 engines, this is a 59A of 46-48 vintage, and the rear main mounts differently.
Photo made it all become clear. You will see the curved raised areas on the outer sides of the main cap, outboard of the main bolt holes.
The original factory machining of the cap extended in an arc directly lined with the arc of those raised alignment ridges to the seal area and left marks.
Plain.
Ready to tear my hair out (after it grows back):

Couple of phone calls worth, finally a picture.
Why are there grooves out of the rear main seal housing in the main cap? Are they oil drains?
Most of my work is on 49-53 engines, this is a 59A of 46-48 vintage, and the rear main mounts differently.
Photo made it all become clear. You will see the curved raised areas on the outer sides of the main cap, outboard of the main bolt holes.
The original factory machining of the cap extended in an arc directly lined with the arc of those raised alignment ridges to the seal area and left marks.
Plain.
Ready to tear my hair out (after it grows back):

Dave....gone by invitation
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 40 guests