Ebay Bargain? of the Week
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13676
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
Had to look that up. I believe, but am not sure, that MTH Made the UP coal turbine.
I may go for a die cast Veranda some day- right after I capture a die cast Bipolar and hopefully purchase a Sunset Skytop in aluminum and brass, not counting window glazing.
I may go for a die cast Veranda some day- right after I capture a die cast Bipolar and hopefully purchase a Sunset Skytop in aluminum and brass, not counting window glazing.
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
The last time one of these sold (in the last year) to my knowledge was by Brasstrains for $6500 and that was record money. Most of the time they bring closer to $5000-5500.
Just another eBay clown going for stupid money, like the guy who wanted $20K for some Wasatch cars and some OMI or KEY E units. Wasn't worth half the asking price. Both of these guys are totally out of touch with reality and must believe the Gordon Gekko speech stating "Greed is Good".
BH
Just another eBay clown going for stupid money, like the guy who wanted $20K for some Wasatch cars and some OMI or KEY E units. Wasn't worth half the asking price. Both of these guys are totally out of touch with reality and must believe the Gordon Gekko speech stating "Greed is Good".
BH
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
up148 wrote:Just another eBay clown going for stupid money, like the guy who wanted $20K for some Wasatch cars and some OMI or KEY E units. Wasn't worth half the asking price. Both of these guys are totally out of touch with reality and must believe the Gordon Gekko speech stating "Greed is Good".BH
That's why I put the ? mark behind "bargain". A bargain for the seller!
Rich
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
Indeed entertaining, if not a scary commentary on consumption.
I'm glad Butch checked in because in my mind he's the "go to" here for all things UP in 1:48.
I'll restate my puzzlement over the Steam Turbine; do these OMI models have real cachet (aka "fierce dragon energy") with the UP faithful?
because again candidly even if I was a UP modeling fan I'm not sure I'd bite on these even if they ran well.
Now say if that whole prototype experiment went well, as opposed to reality, and the UP and Westinghouse or Alco-GE actually floated out a production run of these then it would be a different story, you know assuming something akin to the gas turbines, perhaps with a larger tender and a unique car body set albeit with a cab, "century" or "universal" style front end.
But the prototype looks like it was kit-bashed by a (albeit highly skilled) kid and lasted as long as a soft serve cone on hot pavement.
So weird.
Pete
I'm glad Butch checked in because in my mind he's the "go to" here for all things UP in 1:48.
I'll restate my puzzlement over the Steam Turbine; do these OMI models have real cachet (aka "fierce dragon energy") with the UP faithful?
because again candidly even if I was a UP modeling fan I'm not sure I'd bite on these even if they ran well.
Now say if that whole prototype experiment went well, as opposed to reality, and the UP and Westinghouse or Alco-GE actually floated out a production run of these then it would be a different story, you know assuming something akin to the gas turbines, perhaps with a larger tender and a unique car body set albeit with a cab, "century" or "universal" style front end.
But the prototype looks like it was kit-bashed by a (albeit highly skilled) kid and lasted as long as a soft serve cone on hot pavement.
So weird.
Pete
Political Consultant- Tap into the hidden powers of your public office, insure your future is jail free, well funded. Visit shock and awe upon your adversaries, dominate the media, thrill your followers. contact morbo@happydaysrhereagain.com
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
Pete, No doubt about it, Butch is for sure the go to guy for UP. Hope he pops back in and offers more insight on the turbines. I'm sure he has forgotten more than I ever knew, and particularly about the model versions.
What I think drives the desire for this type of stuff, is that there are a bunch of people in this hobby that like UNUSUAL/DIFFERENT models, even if they go a bit contrary to reality. My favorite example is the 3 dome coal tar tankers that only went eight miles between steel plants, never seeing interchange service. The turbines fit that bill and this one in particular, I think. It is for sure a strange duck.
If I were a UP modeler, I don't think I'd want but one of them, and it wouldn't be the one we're discussing for reasons you have stated. I think the real ones performed well, but like the Coneheads of SNL, they consumed mass quantities of fuel.
Rich
What I think drives the desire for this type of stuff, is that there are a bunch of people in this hobby that like UNUSUAL/DIFFERENT models, even if they go a bit contrary to reality. My favorite example is the 3 dome coal tar tankers that only went eight miles between steel plants, never seeing interchange service. The turbines fit that bill and this one in particular, I think. It is for sure a strange duck.
If I were a UP modeler, I don't think I'd want but one of them, and it wouldn't be the one we're discussing for reasons you have stated. I think the real ones performed well, but like the Coneheads of SNL, they consumed mass quantities of fuel.
Rich
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
Bob, MTH made the Veranda and Turbine in 2Rail. The bodies were plastic, not die cast.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/MTH-2124S-Unio ... Swdrhbxf7o


https://www.ebay.com/itm/MTH-2124S-Unio ... Swdrhbxf7o


Running that red block Charlie.
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
woopy the guy is still dreaming and 4400 to much. 5300- 5500 tops told me he found it is an estate sale
ad did not have a clue what its worth.
Bill
ad did not have a clue what its worth.
Bill
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
This is one UP Turbine model I never owned. In the mid 2000's I saw a couple sell in the $4500 range, but it's strictly a mantle piece, as the radius to run that "B" unit is like 80". So, when I saw BT get $6500 for one, I just thought to myself "well BT snagged another one". But, this EB seller is way over the top!
Remarkable loco and one of OMI's finest detailed models. OMI "knocked out of the park" on this model, but again, it's strictly a display item for 99% of the people. They weren't that well received, even when new ($6700 or 6900 list price), as OMI had new stock for many, many years and then discounted them to get them off the shelf. It was the most expensive model they ever imported and you could buy several very rare and collectable models for that kind of money, when it came out. Too expensive for me, as I had to buy and resell models, making a little here and there to be able to afford what I wanted to keep.....and this model just didn't seem like a good bet.
And, MTH wasted no time bringing out their 3R model of this loco, which took care of many of the 3R UP guys who used to buy some 2R, just to have it in their collection. And, the MTH model was a very nice looking model too.....just the usual compromises for 3R operation. You had to be a hard core UP guy to go after one of these OMI models.
It will be interesting to see where it ends up. We seem to be going through a very strange time in brass prices. Rare items can bring record money, yet more common items are still way off. The Seacrest auctions killed the KEY diesel market, at least for the next couple of years and I expect we'll see a lot more of that scenario (dumping large collections) that will destabilize pricing for some time if not forever.
Just like it's always been, only buy what you love or intend to enjoy working on, because getting your money back or a profit is rare these days.
Butch
Remarkable loco and one of OMI's finest detailed models. OMI "knocked out of the park" on this model, but again, it's strictly a display item for 99% of the people. They weren't that well received, even when new ($6700 or 6900 list price), as OMI had new stock for many, many years and then discounted them to get them off the shelf. It was the most expensive model they ever imported and you could buy several very rare and collectable models for that kind of money, when it came out. Too expensive for me, as I had to buy and resell models, making a little here and there to be able to afford what I wanted to keep.....and this model just didn't seem like a good bet.
And, MTH wasted no time bringing out their 3R model of this loco, which took care of many of the 3R UP guys who used to buy some 2R, just to have it in their collection. And, the MTH model was a very nice looking model too.....just the usual compromises for 3R operation. You had to be a hard core UP guy to go after one of these OMI models.
It will be interesting to see where it ends up. We seem to be going through a very strange time in brass prices. Rare items can bring record money, yet more common items are still way off. The Seacrest auctions killed the KEY diesel market, at least for the next couple of years and I expect we'll see a lot more of that scenario (dumping large collections) that will destabilize pricing for some time if not forever.
Just like it's always been, only buy what you love or intend to enjoy working on, because getting your money back or a profit is rare these days.
Butch
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
Butch,
Thanks for your comments! It is no doubt, an unusual and interesting locomotive. I'll bet the real world version was something to behold!
Rich
Thanks for your comments! It is no doubt, an unusual and interesting locomotive. I'll bet the real world version was something to behold!
Rich
- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42229
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
up148 wrote:We seem to be going through a very strange time in brass prices. Rare items can bring record money, yet more common items are still way off. The Seacrest auctions killed the KEY diesel market, at least for the next couple of years and I expect we'll see a lot more of that scenario (dumping large collections) that will destabilize pricing for some time if not forever.
Maybe it's just a reality check.
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
- Erik C Lindgren
- Posts: 1307
- Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2010 11:37 pm
- Contact:
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
I buy my models because I want them; not because I plan to resell them for a profit. Never have never will. I really could care less about the market unless it’s a model I want and if it’s grossly overpriced like this one well then I won’t have that model. No sale
- Erik C Lindgren
- Posts: 1307
- Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2010 11:37 pm
- Contact:
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
Rufus T. Firefly wrote:up148 wrote:We seem to be going through a very strange time in brass prices. Rare items can bring record money, yet more common items are still way off. The Seacrest auctions killed the KEY diesel market, at least for the next couple of years and I expect we'll see a lot more of that scenario (dumping large collections) that will destabilize pricing for some time if not forever.
Maybe it's just a reality check.
Indeed
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
What ever became of the 25k steam engine? Did someone actually buy it?
Running that red block Charlie.
Re: Ebay Bargain? of the Week
Jon,
I don't think it ever sold, or maybe I should say, I never saw that it sold. It was of ZERO value to me. Others opinions of it's value may differ.
Rich
I don't think it ever sold, or maybe I should say, I never saw that it sold. It was of ZERO value to me. Others opinions of it's value may differ.
Rich
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 38 guests

