I'll stick up for Stu's drives juuuuuuust a little bit here.
They were stellar for their time. That time is long gone and therein is the caveat.
That was an era of open frames, Marn-o-stats, plywood gradeless basement loops, and people too lasy to lube their stuff when that stuff needed operator servicing. I have owned several, and still have an RS3 with his drive. Ball bearings, tapped oilports in the axle boxes, yep a clutch, big begger of an openframe, flywheels, all mechanical solutions to what were the problems of the era.
That era is gone, with nice low end power delivery from modern electronic throttles, DCC, cans (especially the high-end ones), gearheads, &c.
I really disagree with the notion these were bad switchers; that was what they were brilliant at in those days and I still love cracking out that old Kemtron RS for switching. Lovely. Where the clutch absolutely sucks is in mainline service with grades, clutching out on the way up with any load. If you knew them, though, you knew how to lock the clutch off-line (at least my few had lockable clutches). Then they made good mainline locos; some of the most capable of their time.
They were the best of their day, well-engineered and well-executed, but in today's world they are terribly antiquated.
MMW at Chicago
Re: MMW at Chicago
Good Information Sarge. I've never seen the diesel clutch drive in operation, but Stu's steam locomotive drives are fantastic. I know many guys who have them and swear by them. Quiet, strong and built for a lifetime of operation.
BH
BH
Re: MMW at Chicago
Sarge,
Thanks for the enlightenment. There's usually more than one side to a story.
Rich
Thanks for the enlightenment. There's usually more than one side to a story.
Rich
Re: MMW at Chicago
Reading what Peter posted earlier, I have to wonder whether he had an unadulterated Kleinschmit drive or someone's cob-job install of a clutch onto that hateful 1:1 OMI Ajin tower, then sold as a "Kleinschmit", just because it had a clutch, by ignorance or by fraud. An Overland BL2, perchance?
Certainly it sounds nothing like anything I ever owned or worked on that I knew to really be Stu's, but mine were and are all older component drives in older models, my Kemtron RS3 typical of the breed. The execution was bombproof and the engineering excellent.
Certainly it sounds nothing like anything I ever owned or worked on that I knew to really be Stu's, but mine were and are all older component drives in older models, my Kemtron RS3 typical of the breed. The execution was bombproof and the engineering excellent.
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: MMW at Chicago
Sarge,
Not to take this any further than need be, the models I worked on were definitely Stu's. I'll stand by what I said earlier. I can't, and won't, comment on things I haven't actually seen or worked on. Too much of that goes on already. You've had great experiences with them, I haven't. I suppose the running characteristics of a model are somewhat like beauty. It's in the eye of the beholder or, in this case, it's subjective. I wasn't impressed. I'm probably pickier than most. Not saying you are not.
Having said that, I have three USH models of SP steam engines with his drives installed and they are spectacular. One of them is a cab forward with two motors. It runs as well as anything else I've seen.
Jay
Not to take this any further than need be, the models I worked on were definitely Stu's. I'll stand by what I said earlier. I can't, and won't, comment on things I haven't actually seen or worked on. Too much of that goes on already. You've had great experiences with them, I haven't. I suppose the running characteristics of a model are somewhat like beauty. It's in the eye of the beholder or, in this case, it's subjective. I wasn't impressed. I'm probably pickier than most. Not saying you are not.
Having said that, I have three USH models of SP steam engines with his drives installed and they are spectacular. One of them is a cab forward with two motors. It runs as well as anything else I've seen.
Jay
Re: MMW at Chicago
Thanks for the informative discussion, I knowingly have 2 of Stu's drives.
One is in a reworked Max Gray AC-4 cab forward, the other is in a
scratch-built gas-electric motor-and-trailer set that I picked up at
Strasburg in last October's show. May have others, but those two are
the only ones I KNOW are Kleinschmidt's work.
I was starting to get worried when I was reading some of the earlier
posts about the antiquated and problematic clutches and other
mechanical solutions used in the Kleinschmidt drives. So, I
gather the steam drives are pretty good, while the diesel drives
can be problematic when trying to switch and while running upgrade
with a heavy train?
Haven't checked the gas-electric, but I assume that it has a "diesel
locomotive" type drive, but will do so when I dig it out the next time.
And I must also confess to getting confused when I first read about
the "problems" with the C&LS drives. Haven't had any problems with
my C&LS locomotives, both the SP 4-10-2's, and the two FM H-24-66
Trainmaster diesels. I think that Henry did excellent work (opinion),
so I was relieve to find out that the "problem" being discussed was
a case of mistaken identity.
One is in a reworked Max Gray AC-4 cab forward, the other is in a
scratch-built gas-electric motor-and-trailer set that I picked up at
Strasburg in last October's show. May have others, but those two are
the only ones I KNOW are Kleinschmidt's work.
I was starting to get worried when I was reading some of the earlier
posts about the antiquated and problematic clutches and other
mechanical solutions used in the Kleinschmidt drives. So, I
gather the steam drives are pretty good, while the diesel drives
can be problematic when trying to switch and while running upgrade
with a heavy train?
Haven't checked the gas-electric, but I assume that it has a "diesel
locomotive" type drive, but will do so when I dig it out the next time.
And I must also confess to getting confused when I first read about
the "problems" with the C&LS drives. Haven't had any problems with
my C&LS locomotives, both the SP 4-10-2's, and the two FM H-24-66
Trainmaster diesels. I think that Henry did excellent work (opinion),
so I was relieve to find out that the "problem" being discussed was
a case of mistaken identity.
Take care,
Wolfgang
Wolfgang
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: MMW at Chicago
Hey Wolf,
Did I ever reply to your message about doing your Little Joe? At least I think that's what we were talking about a year ago.
Jay
Did I ever reply to your message about doing your Little Joe? At least I think that's what we were talking about a year ago.
Jay
Re: MMW at Chicago
Jay--
Nope...wasn't a Little Joe, but was a Bipolar and I'm still interested.
Nope...wasn't a Little Joe, but was a Bipolar and I'm still interested.
Take care,
Wolfgang
Wolfgang
-
Jay Criswell
- Posts: 2004
- Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2008 12:38 pm
Re: MMW at Chicago
Wolf,
I'll email you.
Jay
I'll email you.
Jay
Re: MMW at Chicago
Jay Criswell wrote:Sarge,
Not to take this any further than need be, the models I worked on were definitely Stu's. I'll stand by what I said earlier. I can't, and won't, comment on things I haven't actually seen or worked on. Too much of that goes on already. You've had great experiences with them, I haven't. I suppose the running characteristics of a model are somewhat like beauty. It's in the eye of the beholder or, in this case, it's subjective. I wasn't impressed. I'm probably pickier than most. Not saying you are not.
Having said that, I have three USH models of SP steam engines with his drives installed and they are spectacular. One of them is a cab forward with two motors. It runs as well as anything else I've seen.
Jay
I don't see this as argument, so no worries from my end.
I'm very much the same way about commenting regarding stuff I haven't had in my hands or in my shop. Actually it might be interesting if there was a decline in qualities over the years, and we are looking at work from two different eras. Mine, both steam and diesel, were all from the the same time as your steam locos, the Max and USH era, and it could be that was his heyday for I have the same view as you do of your USH steam engines.
The only one I have left is my Kemtron RS3, which is from that same era. It is as good as they came back then, a excellent runner today with the clutch locked out, and a truly fun flat switcher with it in line. That said, its crap with a heavy train on grades or MU'd with anything with the clutch unlocked; its an antiquated solution to problems that arguably don't exist anymore. Other than for starting performance using old control gear like Marnostats, I agree the clutch itself today is a novelty if not a liability.
It is not a modern drive, and I'm not surprised a back-emf decoder can't understand it. Perhaps my best description is this. I can't say a Model A is even useful in today's world, but I also can't say a Model A is of poor quality either. Its just hopelessly antiquated.
I can also say none of mine used a 1:1 tower reduction and they also ran well with the clutch locked on modern DC power supplies. Makes me wonder if he was consistent over the years.
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 36 guests