Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
So I was surfing around the web researching something with weathering and came across this video...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mt_pB6yOg0Y
I've seen this Ralph guy before over on model railroad hobbyist. One of their published weathering guys. Personally, I think Mike Confalone is the best guy they have over there for weathering and they should try to get him to do more types and colors of cars to complete his series.
Anyway, in the video above, Ralph clearly uses a bunch of images that were in OST #40 (http://www.oscalemag.com/docs/ost_40.pdf) back in 2008 and never credits Rich Divizio or OST. Maybe its all kosher, but it was very surprising that there was no mention of Ralph or OST and that he talked like he did all of the work...Even if Rich gave him photos and permission, I would bet that OST still own the rights to the images, yes?
Not trying to make a fuss as it was done to help the hobby, but I found it really interesting that no credit was given to Rich or OST with this.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mt_pB6yOg0Y
I've seen this Ralph guy before over on model railroad hobbyist. One of their published weathering guys. Personally, I think Mike Confalone is the best guy they have over there for weathering and they should try to get him to do more types and colors of cars to complete his series.
Anyway, in the video above, Ralph clearly uses a bunch of images that were in OST #40 (http://www.oscalemag.com/docs/ost_40.pdf) back in 2008 and never credits Rich Divizio or OST. Maybe its all kosher, but it was very surprising that there was no mention of Ralph or OST and that he talked like he did all of the work...Even if Rich gave him photos and permission, I would bet that OST still own the rights to the images, yes?
Not trying to make a fuss as it was done to help the hobby, but I found it really interesting that no credit was given to Rich or OST with this.
Focus: 2R O-Scale, SOU/SCL 1967-1972
Blog: http://davejfr0.blogspot.com/
Blog: http://davejfr0.blogspot.com/
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
the arrangement between Rich and OST may not have been exclusive use. technically credit for someone else's material should be given, at the very least, for courtesy of use. though at times the property owner should make clear use of their material requires permission or credit.
if in doubt, err on the side of propriety.
if in doubt, err on the side of propriety.
I am John Galt.
Chris
Chris
- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42227
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
PRR Man wrote:the arrangement between Rich and OST may not have been exclusive use.
Right off the OST web site:
When we pay you for an article we are buying the “first serial rights worldwide”, that is the right to publish your article exclusively in OST and distribute it anywhere in the world. We retain that exclusive right for 6 months from the date of publication in the magazine. After that, the copyright reverts to the author and you can do what you like with the article.
technically credit for someone else's material should be given, at the very least, for courtesy of use. though at times the property owner should make clear use of their material requires permission or credit.
And in this case the person should have gone back to the author for permission....
if in doubt, err on the side of propriety.
Sadly, in this day and age, there is little sense of propriety in play.........
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
-
Chris Rock
- Posts: 1480
- Joined: Fri Sep 23, 2005 6:08 pm
- Location: United States
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
Unless he was using a pen name in one or the other situations and they are the same person, or he got permission from the artist, then he is not allowed to show what he just showed on youtube.
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
Chris is correct. It is actionable in court. Probably not worth it - you should see how often it happens on the OGR forum using the "repeat the entire post" button.
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
bob turner wrote:Chris is correct. It is actionable in court. Probably not worth it - you should see how often it happens on the OGR forum using the "repeat the entire post" button.
lol, wish there was an easier way to not have every photo drug back a 2nd time through.
Focus: 2R O-Scale, SOU/SCL 1967-1972
Blog: http://davejfr0.blogspot.com/
Blog: http://davejfr0.blogspot.com/
- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42227
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
DaveJfr0 wrote:bob turner wrote:Chris is correct. It is actionable in court. Probably not worth it - you should see how often it happens on the OGR forum using the "repeat the entire post" button.
lol, wish there was an easier way to not have every photo drug back a 2nd time through.
There is this key off to the one side on most keyboards - Delete. It seems that an inordinate number of the denizens of OGR have yet to locate it or understand its function or usage. Perhaps they could get some remedial tutelage from some 5 year old children?
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
No- they should just get rid of the "reply with quote" button. It quite often passes the absurd, with ten nested subsequent posts.
- riogrande491
- Posts: 80
- Joined: Thu Aug 09, 2012 8:50 pm
- Location: Northern Colorado
- Contact:
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
If Rich becomes aware of the copyright violation, he can lodge a complaint with Youtube and ask that the video be taken down. That happens all the time. Recently several videos posted to Trainorders were removed from Youtube because their copyright owner complained. The person(s) responsible were also kicked off Trainorders.
Recently I found out that one of my photos was posted on a Toyota-fan web site without attribution nor permission. When I find out, I either a) make the photo disappear, or b) replace it with a big copyright violation banner. For b) I replace the photo with a new one in my photo hosting account. Below is the photo, which shows what Tix acid flux can do in two months. Today the red wire is black, just like some wires in my 1980s Overland diesels.

Recently I found out that one of my photos was posted on a Toyota-fan web site without attribution nor permission. When I find out, I either a) make the photo disappear, or b) replace it with a big copyright violation banner. For b) I replace the photo with a new one in my photo hosting account. Below is the photo, which shows what Tix acid flux can do in two months. Today the red wire is black, just like some wires in my 1980s Overland diesels.

Bob
A&O Historical Society
A&O Historical Society
-
Chris Rock
- Posts: 1480
- Joined: Fri Sep 23, 2005 6:08 pm
- Location: United States
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
Rufus T. Firefly wrote:DaveJfr0 wrote:bob turner wrote:Chris is correct. It is actionable in court. Probably not worth it - you should see how often it happens on the OGR forum using the "repeat the entire post" button.
lol, wish there was an easier way to not have every photo drug back a 2nd time through.
There is this key off to the one side on most keyboards - Delete. It seems that an inordinate number of the denizens of OGR have yet to locate it or understand its function or usage. Perhaps they could get some remedial tutelage from some 5 year old children?
It is funny how it works, but when someone is clearly quoting someone else in the thread, at least that is attribution. The guy on youtube is taking credit for the work as his own which is pretty blatant.
I wonder how many quotes one can get inside of their post until the machine itself calls uncle or Bob's head explodes.
- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42227
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
Chris Rock wrote:Rufus T. Firefly wrote:DaveJfr0 wrote:
lol, wish there was an easier way to not have every photo drug back a 2nd time through.
There is this key off to the one side on most keyboards - Delete. It seems that an inordinate number of the denizens of OGR have yet to locate it or understand its function or usage. Perhaps they could get some remedial tutelage from some 5 year old children?
It is funny how it works, but when someone is clearly quoting someone else in the thread, at least that is attribution. The guy on youtube is taking credit for the work as his own which is pretty blatant.
I wonder how many quotes one can get inside of their post until the machine itself calls uncle or Bob's head explodes.
Hmmm...........don't know - there used to be limits....
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
bob turner wrote:No- they should just get rid of the "reply with quote" button. It quite often passes the absurd, with ten nested subsequent posts.
The PROBLEM is NOT the BUTTON, but the IDIOTS that use it, and do not bother to edit out all the excess verbiage. If you are going to quote someone, you damn well better give them attribution.
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
Looks like someone replied to my reply on the video...
santafeprototypes
4 hours ago
Ralph DID NOT do this car even though he leads you to believe its all his. Called them out and my comments just get deleted....what a bunch of liars. Rich has even commented and his comments were deleted. Bunch of liars associated with this group.
Surprised Rich didn't go to youtube or just threaten lawsuit. That would prob be enough to protect his work.
santafeprototypes
4 hours ago
Ralph DID NOT do this car even though he leads you to believe its all his. Called them out and my comments just get deleted....what a bunch of liars. Rich has even commented and his comments were deleted. Bunch of liars associated with this group.
Surprised Rich didn't go to youtube or just threaten lawsuit. That would prob be enough to protect his work.
Focus: 2R O-Scale, SOU/SCL 1967-1972
Blog: http://davejfr0.blogspot.com/
Blog: http://davejfr0.blogspot.com/
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
This is dangerous ground unless you are dam careful.
First off, the material and the work was submitted to us as Rich's intellectual property. He should click the little flag icon under the video itself and follow the prompts to have the video taken down for infringement.
Youtubemodelbuilders.com are the "publishers" and as such really aren't reasonably able to vet each "author's" submissions. They do have a responsibility, just like we at OST would, to come back to that video and attribute the images in the first half to Rich, or pull it down themselves, either of which would be the proper and honourable thing to do.
The author is the one responsible. I can only say Rich submitted the same images of the same body of work to us that Ralph submitted to You-tube Model Builders. Not to call anyone into question since it isn't our place (more on that in a minute) one really cannot even definitively say whose work it really is, if I'm honest. We published it as Rich's first.
As far as OST's stake in this, we hold exclusive right to distribute once accepted and paid for six months after publication. That has long expired so the original material can be done with as the owner of that material sees fit. He can submit it to someone else, blog it, clinics, whatever he wants to do with no permissions required from us after the right do distribute agreements have expired.
The quirk in all this is that the article in the form published remains under copyright to OST. Our crops, our edits, our layout, remain under copyright to OST. To see if we have been "violated" provably and we could submit a pull-down, I sat down and watched the video with the magazine in hand and followed along. Ralph's "text" is different. The order of the photos is the same, but that isn't anything. What is very interesting is that many of the crops are slightly different. Some actually show more of the original image than our crops in the magazine. Getting the image from us you can use the same crop or crop it further, but its dam difficult to uncrop. So after being very careful before throwing our dog in this fight, I can safely say the pdf on the website and the magazine as published are not the sources of the images. That's where our options legally end, I'm afraid.
So, we can't prove they came from OST, and at least some of the photos had to have come from a different source as they are cropped less than ours. It's therefore on Rich as owner of his intellectual property, Ralph as the user, and youtubemodelbuilders, to sort. Much as I'd enjoy playing, we are out of it on this one.
First off, the material and the work was submitted to us as Rich's intellectual property. He should click the little flag icon under the video itself and follow the prompts to have the video taken down for infringement.
Youtubemodelbuilders.com are the "publishers" and as such really aren't reasonably able to vet each "author's" submissions. They do have a responsibility, just like we at OST would, to come back to that video and attribute the images in the first half to Rich, or pull it down themselves, either of which would be the proper and honourable thing to do.
The author is the one responsible. I can only say Rich submitted the same images of the same body of work to us that Ralph submitted to You-tube Model Builders. Not to call anyone into question since it isn't our place (more on that in a minute) one really cannot even definitively say whose work it really is, if I'm honest. We published it as Rich's first.
As far as OST's stake in this, we hold exclusive right to distribute once accepted and paid for six months after publication. That has long expired so the original material can be done with as the owner of that material sees fit. He can submit it to someone else, blog it, clinics, whatever he wants to do with no permissions required from us after the right do distribute agreements have expired.
The quirk in all this is that the article in the form published remains under copyright to OST. Our crops, our edits, our layout, remain under copyright to OST. To see if we have been "violated" provably and we could submit a pull-down, I sat down and watched the video with the magazine in hand and followed along. Ralph's "text" is different. The order of the photos is the same, but that isn't anything. What is very interesting is that many of the crops are slightly different. Some actually show more of the original image than our crops in the magazine. Getting the image from us you can use the same crop or crop it further, but its dam difficult to uncrop. So after being very careful before throwing our dog in this fight, I can safely say the pdf on the website and the magazine as published are not the sources of the images. That's where our options legally end, I'm afraid.
So, we can't prove they came from OST, and at least some of the photos had to have come from a different source as they are cropped less than ours. It's therefore on Rich as owner of his intellectual property, Ralph as the user, and youtubemodelbuilders, to sort. Much as I'd enjoy playing, we are out of it on this one.
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: Helping the hobby or did someone rip off O Scale Trains and Rich Divizio?
Chris Rock wrote:Rufus T. Firefly wrote:DaveJfr0 wrote:
lol, wish there was an easier way to not have every photo drug back a 2nd time through.
There is this key off to the one side on most keyboards - Delete. It seems that an inordinate number of the denizens of OGR have yet to locate it or understand its function or usage. Perhaps they could get some remedial tutelage from some 5 year old children?
It is funny how it works, but when someone is clearly quoting someone else in the thread, at least that is attribution. The guy on youtube is taking credit for the work as his own which is pretty blatant.
I wonder how many quotes one can get inside of their post until the machine itself calls uncle or Bob's head explodes.
Hot digs! I did not know we could do this here. Too bad there are no photos in this nest.
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 63 guests