ScaleCraft wrote:Depends on whether you have switches or not. And have to have live frogs....or jumper around....
AC in to a transformer. Find and wire in a rectumfrier. Add fuses. Wire in reverse switch. Connect to two rails...oh, wait, once I get past the switch, what happens now?.
Or, plug your ZW in and clip the lockon onto the rails.
We can argue this all day long.
OK, only one example of apples and oranges and (Bob D -Grin!) grapes. Since we've successfully hijacked poor Carey's thread into a debate about Dems and Repub- no sorry two-rail power, three-rail-power, battery, some thoughts.
First off, I'm using Dave's argument above only illustrate a point, not to argue with or slam Dave. Everyone who champions some sort of blind fealty to a control system does this, though. "(Your foolish choice), Get a shovel and dig up some selenium and copper and iron, scratchbuild a power supply, go through every detail or (my superb choice of religion)
just hook up two wires/a lockon/a battery and bask in my intellectual magnificence." The problem with it all is, first off, its not a valid comparison and, second off, someone will follow it seeking enlightenment and really discover they've been had.
The valid comparison point is this. It is easier to hook up two wires than to wire in any control system properly. If you compare a well-done installation to a well-done installation, many of the arguments for one or the other fall away, two of which are ease of operator use and reliability.
A properly done model railroad control system never requires just two wires. (Scace's Fifth Law of Model Railroading). That means your deadrail prayer group too, Delridge, so stop raising your hand and going "Ooh oooh! Pick Me!" Grin!
I can take you down to my cellar and throw the switches on my layout after a year's slumber (It's happened due to a combination of things like the mag, health, aged parents) and I know it will run flawlessly even with the cobwebs. It's two rail traditional DC. Why? I took the time to do the installation properly, busses, drops, feeds, real toggles and rotaries (not that Chinese miniaturised crap from MR adverts or Radio Shack), soldered joints with expansion joints, the whole schtick.
My previous layout was the same way, that one DCC. No two-wires to the rails crap, a hot-loop buss, all the same things and all the same care. Anyone that tells you DCC needs somehow less wiring to do it properly is giving you a reach-around from behind. "Proper" equals isolation blocks, feeds and drops, wiring the turnouts properly, and you get apples to apples. Add to it your decoder installation. You are doing it yourself, aren't you?
Three rail? When we first got married, my wife was very much into Dept. 56 collecting. So, why not crack out my old Hornby and Lionel and build a layout for her to display these things? A large layout in three rail (sorry, Dave, but the bullshit flag thrown here) needs every bit the same amount of care and wiring expended. I'll be honest, three-rail wiring for reliable operation was about as non-intuitive for me after decades of two-rail as two-rail wiring is to the Hirail crowd. I had to crack out an old Fawcett Crest handbook (remember those) and teach myself how to think three-rail. Not hard, but different.
I venture to guess the vast majority of whinging three-railers get on about regarding their TMCC or DCS not working to expectation is due to the "two wire" myth, then they get all bristly when they have to buy a Barry book that tells 'em how to do it right. It's easier to blame the system (and repeat the two-rail is so very hard myth while they're at it). Do it properly, and apples to apples.
Your turn, Bob. Battery RC is on the surface easy. No wires, no toggles, no insulated rail, what could be simpler? Ha! I've gone down this road, too, so the dirty petticoats the deadrail people carefully hide can be outed. Your wiring is still there, just under the shell rather than in the fascia of the layout. Unless you're checkbooking it, you wire
each loco with the complete control system and power supply in miniature. You can slap it in or you can do it properly without an isolation toggle and a recharge point sticking out the side ruining the appearance of the loco. Solder your rail too or do something to make the joint alignments robust. Mechanical, not electrical, but still needs addressed. Soldered or otherwise proper robust joints can't only be laid at the feet of the trackpower people. It might be even more important for you, since your stuff can go crawling off like a drunk after closing, un-noticed until the dreaded Thump of Death is heard from the aisle and do it under power. Just a couple examples, but
properly done installations aren't quite a simple as the mythology and evangelism would have the rest of us believe. Solid construction of the trackwork, robust installation of the receiver, power, and modulating circuitry makes for reliability, appearance can be destroyed by poor placement of recharging ports and off/on toggles, yep, battery R/C works fine, but that work needs done to bring it up to a comparable level with any other properly done control system. I've seen it done well, and I've done it in O and #1 myself, so the ease and simplicity bit (and Tammy Fae crying real tears of rapture) is a bit wasted on me.
So, understanding three-rail is not difficult for a guy who came up in two-rail, but it has its foibles you need to learn to do it properly.
The reversed case is just as true to do two rail properly, but it isn't any "harder".
DCC is no easier than DC to do properly and you get sound out of the deal if that's important to you, but you get to learn loco installs or buy them and pay for the maintenance too because you bought the install and have no idea how to repair it. Personal choice there.
Same for three-rail vs command. Properly done it works reliably, and you get sound as a payoff for the additional work of the electronics in the loco. Again you either add that task or you give up some independence by checkbooking installs and repairs because you have no idea how to fix what was installed by Chinese girls or your DCS guy.
Battery R/c, you give up some failsafes or at least need to think about how to keep locos on the rail, out of the aisles, and off each other but the independence of each loco is the real gain you get for that new risk. Sound is there, but either way you are wiring it up each and every loco or checkbooking and casting your independence to your installer both to put it in (neatly, properly robust, and invisibly, we hope) and to replace a battery pack or two if they start not taking charges. Don't forget to plug it in, be comfy with the notion you are recharging batteries when you are elsewhere so if $hit goes wrong it goes way wrong (a paranoia I have even when recharging a tablet or a phone).
The upshot is each system choice in my view has tradeoffs and advantages that make each person's choice validly their own. None of them are the future to the exclusion of any other. Properly done, and you are now bloody sick of seeing the word here but that is the key to this premise, but properly done each is pretty involved and will give reliable and mostly intuitive control. None are harder or easier for a layout beyond the simple loop, they all require thought, care, and understanding to make work well and you never ever only "hook up two wires and go."