Postby sarge » Wed Sep 30, 2015 6:28 pm
A little clarity perhaps:
The B&M Berk that Tramp shows is a bit unusual in that the ash-pans were mounted on the trailer itself. The early Lima Berkshires and Texas types had no real frame behind the rear driver. Instead, the trailer was pinned to the frame just aft of the rear driving wheel and was also the drawhead for the tender. It erroneously is often called an articulated trailing truck; Lima called it an articulated frame. The idea was to allow for less offset of the drawhead on curves.
The down sides were a few important ones. They didn't like backing through curves pushing a load; light-engine they were ok but backing a train would see the trailer pop off at the slightest flaw in the railhead. Also, because the ashpan had to be mounted on the trailer, a rise or fall at the top or bottom of a grade would vary the airspace between pan and grates, so the burn would be affected. It turned out the Commonwealth design trailer made the articulated frame concept un-necessary, so by the 1930 Boston & Albany Berk order Lima abandoned it. Both subclasses of B&M ones had it, two out of three subclasses of B&As, some of Eries earlier Berks, the T&P 2-10-4s and the CGWs for examples.
I told you all that boring stuff to tell you this. Normal ashpans mounted to the tail of the frame as in normal practice are quite a bit tighter to the bottom of the firebox, so far less obtrusive. They often look like nice edges to the bottom of the box and not much more. On the B&A or B&M Berks, they are out there in front of God and everyone; a much different look.