jwmathews wrote:Never having seen an Egoff model (afaik), I cannot offer an opinion as to authenticity. As to the appearance of the model, it may be that the builder (whomever it was( was trying to model a Pennsy K4 but didn't have all the correct parts to do everything accurately Not having a full front view, I cannot figure out the intend3d appearance of the pilot.
The placement of the sandboc forward of the bell. while not "typical" of the K4, is not totally incorrect. There were at least 20 or so prototypes built this way. I call them the "Lines West" K4, because this forward location of the sandbox (standard on the L1 Mikad'os) was used on locos operating in areas west of Pittsburgh, where some locations had refueling bunkers located above mainline tracks. This arrangement allowed locos to pause without uncoupling from the trains and replenish the sandboxes & fill their tenders without jockeying around. There are published photos of some of these locos. A softcover booklet by Harry Albrecht on the K4s has a few. The most notable examples of this arrangement are probably the four locos streamlined in 1940-41 for the new coach trains operating to St Louis and "The South Wind: between Chicago & Louisville
Of primary consideration, initially, was the catalog photo used to support the photo.
Yes, the PRR changed and modified a lot....so much for the "Standard of the World". But add it up, Woody.
Valve gear, valve gear hanger, crosshead, crosshead guide, dome HEIGHT difference and PLACEMENT, bell placement, class lights, rods, pilot, handrails, actual Belpaire.
Someone who is proud enough of his work to sign units (stamped) and who built as many of these as is claimed 80+ years on...and then compare to photos of a known Egolf K4....and Houston, we have a problem.