R.K. Maroon wrote:It seems to me that the merits of the Lionel 716 scale hopper have been elbowed out of the conversation here so we can all beat up on the Lionel crowd in general (it's been done to death, so no fun for me in that) and the 714 boxcar in particular.
Jim, I was not beating up on the Lionel crowd at all, and will attempt to present the perspective objectively.
It appears discussion of the merits of any of the models you've posted have often wandered off to general comments regarding the entire range it might have come from, to prototype fidelity, and to comparisons regarding the model in question versus its contemporary competition. I submit its fair game here, not unfair "beating up" of any "crowd".
History as a discipline calls into question past interpretation of events (in this case represented by artefacts) for examination or re-examination. There is often proposed a revised interpretation and, in order for that interpretation to gain any validity, events, facts, artefacts, are examined and presented in support. Otherwise, the clinging on to old interpretations by repetition, emotion, &c results, or new unsupported ideas quickly transcend revisionism to conspiracy theory, either pole rejecting analysis for myth.
As far as the 700 series, much has been written in the most exalted terms. To be fair, you laid the range out for discussion when you posted the hopper. Of the range, the hopper is arguably the best model, a representation of the prototype. Not a Pennsy guy, but the B6 might be next in line for fidelity. It all goes pretty much downhill from there as to what is a good model or not.
Earlier, we discussed the merits of the Alexander tank, its prototype, the origin of it as published in the contemporary Carbuilder's, the use of Carbuilders, Locobuilders, and other prototype engineering sources by manufacturers in that era to give us prototype specific models, et al. Its fair. While some like the appearance, proportions, finish, of the 700 series tank as an artefact onto itself, I've never found a prototype although yes many have been used in the scale sector as admittedly very good looking albeit generic filler. In my day, the same was done (barring brass) using the Kusan Auburn tank, likewise without specific prototype but of good proportion and potential, until the advent of the Intermountan and RC kits.
The boxcar in the range has already been discussed, and I'm hesitant to bring up the caboose or the Hudson at this point. I would not be surprised if every item in the range is indeed an attempt at a specific prototype, but I'll need some education regarding the tank and the box as to whether that's true. If it is so, then they really cannot be called equivalent to their contemporaries let alone top-of-the-line simply because they are not successful at recalling their prototype in the same manner as others of the era (the Alexander tank example).
None of this was or is intended as "beating up" on a "crowd". This then brings a question regarding intent of the thread. Is this intended as an objective discussion of the merits of these examples as models and artefacts of our history, or as a celebration of doorstop-dom? If the latter, I respect that and, once knowing that to be the intent, will stay out of it for I'm not really a celebrant in that mould. They interest me as artefacts representing an often misunderstood era worthy of discussion in context, or as models onto themselves, successful or no. Beyond that, I've no interest in them as icons (icon compared to artefact; there is a significant difference) or as items of nostalgia, so should probably not be here unintentionally damping the celebration (or inspiring others to intentionally do so) by bringing interpretation into it when celebration is the intent.
My apologies to all.

