N&W "J"
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
N&W "J"
A question over on NK tinplate: what is the most accurate N&W J?
Being an SP steam nut, I of course have no idea, so I offered an opinion. But the "J" is such a gorgeous piece of machinery i believe an answer is worthwhile.
I own a Williams. It is ok for me - it captures the essence. But I have heard that it has flaws. I believe that two other brass scale versions exist.
So the question: has anybody really done justice to this thing in O Scale?
Being an SP steam nut, I of course have no idea, so I offered an opinion. But the "J" is such a gorgeous piece of machinery i believe an answer is worthwhile.
I own a Williams. It is ok for me - it captures the essence. But I have heard that it has flaws. I believe that two other brass scale versions exist.
So the question: has anybody really done justice to this thing in O Scale?
Re: N&W "J"
Guessing it is a competition between Overland and Sunset, and maybe Max Gray. I do NOT own one, though I've been tempted.
Rich
Rich
-
Chris Rock
- Posts: 1480
- Joined: Fri Sep 23, 2005 6:08 pm
- Location: United States
Re: N&W "J"
There was a really good thread on OGR several years ago on this very topic. Joe G. was involved in the discussion and the thread stands out to me as being greatly informative. The Williams J is a bit stretched out and I think it was put on a NYC 4-8-4 frame. The NYC engine had larger drivers than a J should have so you can imagine the differnece that would cause. Among the others there are plusses and minuses and so many details to discuss. If you took all the best features of each model, you could make a great model.
I own the Overland, Sunset, MTH and Williams models. I've studied the Max Gray and Lionel very closely, too.
I'm most pleased with the Overland but it certainly could use some improvements. I run the Overland and MTH models. The Sunset and Williams models spend most of their time packed under the layout.
I am a real stickler for the front of the overhead shroud and I think MTH and Williams did this part the best. The overhead front of the shroud is the most dissapointing part of the Overland model for me. It is close but isn't quite right there. The front of the overhead shroud on the Sunset model is an absolute disaster. Lionel's isn't quite right, either.
Tandem drive rods are best on the Overland and Sunset. MTH doesn't even try to do the rods correctly, but somehow they come across to me as pretty plausible. The Lionel has the rods pretty well positioned but somehow they still don't look good. You can barely tell they are tandem rods.
Really, too much to get into.
I own the Overland, Sunset, MTH and Williams models. I've studied the Max Gray and Lionel very closely, too.
I'm most pleased with the Overland but it certainly could use some improvements. I run the Overland and MTH models. The Sunset and Williams models spend most of their time packed under the layout.
I am a real stickler for the front of the overhead shroud and I think MTH and Williams did this part the best. The overhead front of the shroud is the most dissapointing part of the Overland model for me. It is close but isn't quite right there. The front of the overhead shroud on the Sunset model is an absolute disaster. Lionel's isn't quite right, either.
Tandem drive rods are best on the Overland and Sunset. MTH doesn't even try to do the rods correctly, but somehow they come across to me as pretty plausible. The Lionel has the rods pretty well positioned but somehow they still don't look good. You can barely tell they are tandem rods.
Really, too much to get into.
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: N&W "J"
I knew you would rise to the occasion. Thanks for the insight.
I only read it once - are you hinting that MTH might be a better choice than Williams?
I only read it once - are you hinting that MTH might be a better choice than Williams?
-
Seaboard Air Line Fan
- Posts: 1308
- Joined: Mon Mar 08, 2004 9:49 pm
- Location: Virginia
Re: N&W "J"
The Williams Crown Edition brass J I have measures just under 72" drivers and approx 112' (28") long. A book I have says they had 70" drivers and 109'-2-1/4" long. The extra length I measured may be nothing more than the extended drawbar on the model.
Big Jim should be chiming in any minute, I know he said his dad helped build these things.
Williams also makes one that to my knowledge is not brass and is semi-scale. It's shorter from what I recall when I saw a friends years back.
Mine is heavy at over 14lbs, had 32oz of lead weight in the boiler.
The Williams brass J can be had on Ebay for around $300-500, I originally upgraded mine to PS2 (sounded and ran great) before I converted it to BPRC. IMO excellent slow speed. One thing mine has and I've read others having the same issue was the nose cone casting paint was/is rough. It comes out so repainting it would be easy, just haven't done it yet. Not sure if all had the problem or not. The boiler paint is fine.
Big Jim should be chiming in any minute, I know he said his dad helped build these things.
Williams also makes one that to my knowledge is not brass and is semi-scale. It's shorter from what I recall when I saw a friends years back.
Mine is heavy at over 14lbs, had 32oz of lead weight in the boiler.
The Williams brass J can be had on Ebay for around $300-500, I originally upgraded mine to PS2 (sounded and ran great) before I converted it to BPRC. IMO excellent slow speed. One thing mine has and I've read others having the same issue was the nose cone casting paint was/is rough. It comes out so repainting it would be easy, just haven't done it yet. Not sure if all had the problem or not. The boiler paint is fine.
BobD aka Drifty
The Crow Flies At Midnight
The Crow Flies At Midnight
Re: N&W "J"
Seaboard Air Line Fan wrote:Williams also makes one that to my knowledge is not brass and is semi-scale. It's shorter from what I recall when I saw a friends years back.
semi-scale: one of the most egregious descriptions used by the 3 rail pimps (pimps meaning vendors) to describe something that is built with measurements that are totally science fiction in regard to 1/48 scale. Similar to semi-pregnant, or semi-dead.
Seaboard Air Line Fan wrote:The Williams brass J can be had on Ebay for around $300-500, I originally upgraded mine to PS2 (sounded and ran great) before I converted it to BPRC. IMO excellent slow speed. One thing mine has and I've read others having the same issue was the nose cone casting paint was/is rough. It comes out so repainting it would be easy, just haven't done it yet. Not sure if all had the problem or not. The boiler paint is fine.
Bob, I think you have identified a problem with at least some of the Williams, because I looked at one of these (or I should say I looked at images) and the nose had bumps/lumps in the paint and looked pretty crappy.
It would be interesting to have a table with the dimensions of the various models and the prototype to compare. In ones I've seen for other locos, none are totally correct , with (mostly) minor differences here and there.
I recall Big Jim commenting regarding his Father's involvement with construction of the J's and I am fairly sure he stated that none of the models got the skyline casing exactly right.
Rich
- Rufus T. Firefly
- Posts: 42220
- Joined: Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 am
- Location: To be Determined
Re: N&W "J"
E7 wrote: semi-scale: one of the most egregious descriptions used by the 3 rail pimps (pimps meaning vendors) to describe something that is built with measurements that are totally science fiction in regard to 1/48 scale. Similar to semi-pregnant, or semi-dead.
Must save this definition for future use over on OGR..................
What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger. It also gives you a lot of unhealthy coping mechanisms, trust issues, and a dark sense of humor.
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: N&W "J"
In 1940 Lionel used the term for scale models on tinplate trucks. Semi-scale freight cars had different underframes, but otherwise were 700-series scale bodies. The term got shanghaied when "tinplate" became pejorative.
-
Chris Rock
- Posts: 1480
- Joined: Fri Sep 23, 2005 6:08 pm
- Location: United States
Re: N&W "J"
Bob,
There are variables that have to do with accuracy and some to due with details that are specific to different timeframes that influenced my decisions.
I compared the Williams about 10 years ago. The Williams was stretched out an extra half inch or so, so Seaboards numbers are about right on and the extra length is not in the drawbar. The extra length is in the engine itself. I seem to recall it had tiny cylenders. I'm 90 percent sure the Williams model has the wrong trucks on the tender for the 611 but it has been a while since I've had it out to make sure. It has the single siderod which is fine for 1956 and later but not earlier.
I've only bought the MTH version more recently. One thing that bothers me most about the MTH J is the windows in the cab are way too short. I think the drivers are a little small on the MTH version, but I won't be replacing them so I did not bother to measure them. The tandem rods on the MTH version are faked but to me isn't too noticeable. The class lights are pretty gross.
For $300 the Williams engine is a lot of engine for sure.
There are variables that have to do with accuracy and some to due with details that are specific to different timeframes that influenced my decisions.
I compared the Williams about 10 years ago. The Williams was stretched out an extra half inch or so, so Seaboards numbers are about right on and the extra length is not in the drawbar. The extra length is in the engine itself. I seem to recall it had tiny cylenders. I'm 90 percent sure the Williams model has the wrong trucks on the tender for the 611 but it has been a while since I've had it out to make sure. It has the single siderod which is fine for 1956 and later but not earlier.
I've only bought the MTH version more recently. One thing that bothers me most about the MTH J is the windows in the cab are way too short. I think the drivers are a little small on the MTH version, but I won't be replacing them so I did not bother to measure them. The tandem rods on the MTH version are faked but to me isn't too noticeable. The class lights are pretty gross.
For $300 the Williams engine is a lot of engine for sure.
-
Chris Rock
- Posts: 1480
- Joined: Fri Sep 23, 2005 6:08 pm
- Location: United States
Re: N&W "J"
Bob,
I just saw the thread on OGR. If you were referring to me as the "most N&W modeler," I appreciate the sentiment but the statement is not close to true and I'd rather not be seen in that way. There are many others I can think of off the top of my head, including Jimmy who are far more knowledgeable than me. It's a little over the top.
I just saw the thread on OGR. If you were referring to me as the "most N&W modeler," I appreciate the sentiment but the statement is not close to true and I'd rather not be seen in that way. There are many others I can think of off the top of my head, including Jimmy who are far more knowledgeable than me. It's a little over the top.
-
Seaboard Air Line Fan
- Posts: 1308
- Joined: Mon Mar 08, 2004 9:49 pm
- Location: Virginia
Re: N&W "J"
semi-scale: one of the most egregious descriptions used by the 3 rail pimps (pimps meaning vendors) to describe something that is built with measurements that are totally science fiction in regard to 1/48 scale. Similar to semi-pregnant, or semi-dead.
The siderods on my J appear to piece individual pieces, connecting one wheel to the next, for a total of 3 per side.
If we can again post photos I'll try to take a couple to show and tell.
BobD aka Drifty
The Crow Flies At Midnight
The Crow Flies At Midnight
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: N&W "J"
I should have said "I regard him as the most knowledgable . . .". I shall be more careful with my opinions.
By the way, I have an MTH Hudson. Cylinders were way undersize on that one. The three rail crowd needs to go around O-72, and that sort of dictates cylinder size.
By the way, I have an MTH Hudson. Cylinders were way undersize on that one. The three rail crowd needs to go around O-72, and that sort of dictates cylinder size.
-
Chris Rock
- Posts: 1480
- Joined: Fri Sep 23, 2005 6:08 pm
- Location: United States
Re: N&W "J"
Okay Bob, as an opinion you are allowed.
Seaboard,
The siderod pieces makes sense.
I refer to the single rod only as opposed to tandem rods.
Seaboard,
The siderod pieces makes sense.
I refer to the single rod only as opposed to tandem rods.
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13675
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: N&W "J"
Here is one for N&W fans. I will reserve opinion on this one. I am going to go look up "charlatan".
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1-ONLY-CUSTOM-M ... Swz~VZnvl8
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1-ONLY-CUSTOM-M ... Swz~VZnvl8
- Arthur P. Bloom
- Posts: 754
- Joined: Wed Dec 13, 2006 6:07 pm
- Location: Eastern Long Island
- Contact:
Re: N&W "J"
"Recommended Age Range: FOR THE DECERNING COLLECTOR"
It probably would run better were the wheels touching the rails. Just sayin'.
It probably would run better were the wheels touching the rails. Just sayin'.
"I'll have the roast duck...with the mango salsa."
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 60 guests
