Page 1 of 1

State of the Art

Posted: Thu Aug 24, 2017 2:11 pm
by E7
Here is a link to an OGR thread about the new Key $7500 cab forward:

https://ogrforum.ogaugerr.com/topic/sou ... el-imports

Thought maybe some would care to comment! A bit out of my wallet capacity for sure, and regret to say, cab forwards don't excite me that much, but it's still fun/interesting to look at. Makes me wonder what the $$$$$$$$ threshold for models might be. The number of pieces in the run was not mentioned, but I'm guessing pretty low. Nice photography by Eric L. as usual.

Rich

Re: State of the Art

Posted: Thu Aug 24, 2017 2:52 pm
by up148
Straight from the horses mouth:

A lot of people find things like the total number of versions of a model to be interesting data. I do, too, so here is the breakdown on the number of each of the SP AC versions that Key brought in:

AC-7 #4156 - 4
AC-7 #4162 - 3 (one without DCC)
AC-7 #4167 - 4
AC-8 #4177 - 8
AC-8 #4179 - 4
AC-8 #4186 - 4 (one without DCC)
AC-10 #4206 - 1
AC-10 #4211 - 4
AC-10 #4225 - 3
AC-11 #4252 - 4
AC-11 #4274 - 5
AC-12 #4284 - 4 (one without DCC)
AC-12 #4286 - 3
AC-12 #4294 - 27

The ones without DCC were extras added on after the builder used up all the DCC decoders. They look just like the others, but only run on straight DC. A total of 78 models in 14 versions.


Not sure if we'll ever see another steam locomotive model built to this level of detail and sophistication. If the KEY Big Boy becomes a reality, then possibly. KOH's lost his Korean builder and went to China, so I really don't expect his BB to be as nice as his Challenger. I don't see any Henry Bultman's on the horizon, so this AC may be the pinnacle steam locomotive model for a long time. But, that is just my opinion.

BH

Re: State of the Art

Posted: Thu Aug 24, 2017 4:34 pm
by Chris Rock
Butch,

Thanks for posting the list. It is an awesome piece.

If Henry Bultman imports another engine, it will without question be the best. It will be manifested only through the hands of God.

Re: State of the Art

Posted: Thu Aug 24, 2017 8:01 pm
by bob turner
I heard somewhere that Japanese labor is now less expensive than Chinese. I am going to guess that the days of inexpensive quality brass are drawing to a close.

I just bought some hydraulic hoses. Double last year's price, and four times the price of just a few years ago. A buddy dropped by, talking about Cessna parts: $1500 for a dip stick! Fifty bucks for a 1/8" npt tee. Not even brass!

Re: State of the Art

Posted: Fri Aug 25, 2017 5:54 am
by E7
up148 wrote:Not sure if we'll ever see another steam locomotive model built to this level of detail and sophistication. If the KEY Big Boy becomes a reality, then possibly. KOH's lost his Korean builder and went to China, so I really don't expect his BB to be as nice as his Challenger. BH


I'm surprised someone hasn't tried LIK Enterprises (or maybe they have??) which was Henry Bultmann's builder after his fallout with Boo Rim, and (I think) the builder of the SP 4-10-2???

up148 wrote:I don't see any Henry Bultman's on the horizon, so this AC may be the pinnacle steam locomotive model for a long time. But, that is just my opinion. BH


How about Erik at Midwestern Model Works? Haven't heard much scuttlebutt from/about them of late, but then I have no skin in the game.

Rich

Re: State of the Art

Posted: Fri Aug 25, 2017 9:24 am
by Rufus T. Firefly
E7 wrote:How about Erik at Midwestern Model Works?


Things are slow......

Why don't you go over to OGR and start a conversation about MMW? That should be good for a few pages of extreme silliness intersecting with fanaticism before it gets locked down and then deleted

Re: State of the Art

Posted: Fri Aug 25, 2017 10:49 am
by E7
The thought crossed my mind! :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

Re: State of the Art

Posted: Fri Aug 25, 2017 11:08 am
by Chris Rock
Rufus T. Firefly wrote:Things are slow......


When ballasting the railroad is more entertaining than the forums, things are pretty slow.

Re: State of the Art

Posted: Fri Aug 25, 2017 11:54 am
by Rufus T. Firefly
Chris Rock wrote:
Rufus T. Firefly wrote:Things are slow......


When ballasting the railroad is more entertaining than the forums, things are pretty slow.


I'm open to suggestions - no one seems willing or interested in sharing heir modeling projects - Robert's H10 is nice.

I'd be happy though to see such a project post here from start to finish.

I have 4 trolley projects going at the same time, but I'm also writing at least 3 different articles from them as well.....and since I don't build shiny things, well, my other projects are consequently of no interest to anyone at all.

Re: State of the Art

Posted: Fri Aug 25, 2017 1:25 pm
by E7
Chris Rock wrote:When ballasting the railroad is more entertaining than the forums, things are pretty slow.


Neville Rossiter has an excellent thread going on a steel mill he is building. His stuff is first rate.