Page 1 of 3
Union Pacific Monster type 4-12-2
Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2017 1:06 pm
by bob turner
Fooling around again with the 4-12-2. Straightening things up, making it smoother, and adding valve gear.
I did not invest in the Kratville books, thinking that I would never build one. But now I see the need for at least one volume. Since these are pricey, I need to choose one for starters.
Current plan is "as built", no external sanders, small sand dome, coal tender, and screens on firebox. Open to hints as to which volume would help me the most with photos of the early locomotive. They are available on eBay at around $150 each.
Re: Union Pacific type
Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2017 3:33 pm
by R.K. Maroon
Bob, I will admit right up front that I can't help you with that. I only know of the book he co-authored with Ranks on UP streamliners. So I did a search and found some discussion about him following his death a few years back:
https://www.trainorders.com/discussion/read.php?1,241723918 books! That's a heck of an accomplishment, among many others.
Jim
Re: Union Pacific type
Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2017 3:37 pm
by Rufus T. Firefly
bob turner wrote:They are available on eBay at around $150 each.
Maybe Amazon?
https://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss ... =Kratville
Re: Union Pacific type
Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2017 4:04 pm
by up148
Bob,
I have both books and will look tonight. If this is something you won't need to keep for a long time, might be able to lend you one. I've got an older SS 9000 I want to update, but the 2-10-2 has moved everything into the queue and it will be months or longer before I even think about it.
If photos will do, I also have books from the UPHS that are B/W photo journals with 2 profile photos (both sides) of each numbered loco, by Jim Ehrenberger. They were a bargain at $15 each and still available. Good sized photos of each loco, but depending on when the photo was taken it might have been modified.
BH
Re: Union Pacific type
Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2017 5:31 pm
by up148
Bob,
The 1st book is 288 pages with the 1st 113 pages dedicated to the 4-10-2 (this is about 3 cylinder power locos). But it covers the 1st loco built and subsequent locos in "as-built" design. Does have lots of photos, drawings and diagrams. Typical sub-assembly photos of frame, firebox, cylinders, drivers, rods, etc.
The 2nd book is 352 pages all dedicated to the 4-12-2 and pretty impressive too. Shows more and different photos, drawings and diagrams of the same type items plus modifications and upgrades that happened and those that didn't.
Your choice or both, it's really hard to choose as one is a great starter and the other just takes it deeper. I won't need them for quite some time.
BH
Re: Union Pacific type
Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2017 8:03 pm
by bob turner
That is a very nice offer. I have not spent much on trains lately, so buying a book is well within the budget. I note that one refill of avgas in the Decathlon is the same as the average price for these books. Hang on to your books, and I will look for Vol 1. I beat the crap out of my books.
I do have the one photo of as-delivered 9000 in the Kratville- Ranks book. I will be studying that for clues - it has already helped with the lubrication ear on the eccentric rods. And I have that spectacular Lionel model to copy!
Re: Union Pacific type
Posted: Fri Jul 21, 2017 9:50 pm
by up148
No problem. Offer stands if you change your mind. I bought mine from Bill Kratville at a show in KCMO back in the early 90's. He used to attend the quarterly train shows, sometimes, with tables of books and photos. But, I was in to collecting trains, instead of knowledge or I would have more than just a couple of books from him.
BH
Re: Union Pacific type
Posted: Mon Jul 24, 2017 2:33 pm
by bob turner
I just bought a copy of Vol I from Chicagoland at what appears to be a very favorable price. Rich has given me some pretty spectacular deals, including a $35 All Nation Mountain. That sounds expensive to Dave, but I still look at it and think how nice Rich has been all these years.
Mechanism is almost complete. Still puzzling through attaching the valve spindles to the Gresley gear, but otherwise mostly tuned up for paint and operation. Air tanks and cab vents on the boiler tonight. I may wait for the book before proceeding with piping. Big decision is feed water system - the Elesco is already soldered on, and not looking forward to chopping the beautiful running board for theWorthington BL.
Re: Union Pacific type
Posted: Mon Jul 24, 2017 2:42 pm
by ScaleCraft
bob turner wrote:I just bought a copy of Vol I from Chicagoland at what appears to be a very favorable price. Rich has given me some pretty spectacular deals, including a $35 All Nation Mountain. That sounds expensive to Dave, but I still look at it and think how nice Rich has been all these years.
Sounds good to me. Have to adjust for inflation.
Re: Union Pacific type
Posted: Tue Jul 25, 2017 9:43 am
by up148
bob turner wrote:I just bought a copy of Vol I from Chicagoland at what appears to be a very favorable price. Rich has given me some pretty spectacular deals, including a $35 All Nation Mountain. That sounds expensive to Dave, but I still look at it and think how nice Rich has been all these years.
Mechanism is almost complete. Still puzzling through attaching the valve spindles to the Gresley gear, but otherwise mostly tuned up for paint and operation. Air tanks and cab vents on the boiler tonight. I may wait for the book before proceeding with piping. Big decision is feed water system - the Elesco is already soldered on, and not looking forward to chopping the beautiful running board for theWorthington BL.
The book might change your mind on the BL feedwater system as many "As- Built" used it. The model SSM imported has this system installed and represents #9000 in early life, although the sanding lines and a few other details are modeled for later modified locos. One thing for sure, like many locos, the 9000's were modified heavily during their operating years, so pick a year and the loco could look different.
BH
Re: Union Pacific type
Posted: Tue Jul 25, 2017 12:30 pm
by bob turner
I do have spare BL castings. What gives me fits is forming that huge steam line with the water separator. I will hold off till the book gets here.
I do like the clean boiler look, with those buried sander lines, and the nice square cab.
Re: Union Pacific type
Posted: Sat Jul 29, 2017 2:17 am
by bob turner
Book arrived. $130, and it is darn near perfect! A quick glance tells me I should have obtained one of these decades ago.
The later models were delivered looking very much like mine - slightly larger sand dome, no sander lines showing, and non-BL feedater heater. I need more research - my Elesco is mounted behind my stack. Not sure why I did that.
I was really ready to cut that big B-L into the left running board until I got to the delivery photos of the UP-3 class. As soon as I finish the frame for my Allegheny tender, I will jump back on this brute.
Today brass was over seven bucks a pound. Wow!
Re: Union Pacific type
Posted: Sat Jul 29, 2017 8:40 am
by E7
bob turner wrote:Book arrived. $130, and it is darn near perfect! A quick glance tells me I should have obtained one of these decades ago.
On that subject, it always amazes me at the reluctance of people to buy BOOKS as references. I have bought a pile of them and have no regrets. Add to that photos, particularly builder photos!
Rich
Re: Union Pacific type
Posted: Mon Jan 14, 2019 9:40 pm
by bob turner
Well, Bump! I tried searching for this thread using its exact title, and the search led me everywhere but here. I am going to try to change either the title or a post to include Union Pacific Monster. Maybe that will be searchable.
Pulled the big monster out, found the tender side pressings, and again tackled this daunting project. Tender is on trucks, awaiting major details (water tank walkway is next) and boiler is getting marked for washouts and lag clamps.
Maybe some photos - I would swear I posted the photos of the Lionel version here, but cannot (agan, finicky search routine) find them. Maybe here . . .
Re: Union Pacific Monster type 4-12-2
Posted: Tue Jan 15, 2019 1:03 am
by bob turner
Well, nuts! I am all set, and cannot find my washout plugs and lag clamps. That's what I get for trying to rearrange and clean up my act. I know I have them; I just bought $30 worth of washout plugs. Life is tough for scratchbuilders. I even had the torch almost lit.