Page 1 of 2
May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Fri Apr 21, 2017 8:29 pm
by RDSRR
May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out:
http://oscaleresource.com/News You Can Use
New Items of Interest
Chicago O Scale Meet 2017
Chicago O Scale Meet Contest Results
Baggage Dormitory Car Part 4
Bill Basen finishes his series on his building of a Texas & Pacific Baggage Dormitory Car
What Are Low-D Wheelsets?
Tad Daito tells us more
It’s Auction Time!
We pay a visit to Stout Auctions to see how train auctions work during the James Seacrest auction
Business Car Matilda
George Paxon builds a business car on the Mountain Electric Railway
Scene Around the Layout
What’s On Your Workbench
March Meet Model Contest Information
Show Schedule
Classified Ads
and so much more ... Thank you for looking.
Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Sun Apr 23, 2017 1:55 am
by webenda
RDSRR wrote:May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out:
http://oscaleresource.com/What Are Low-D Wheelsets? Tad Daito tells us more
Thank you for heads up Dan.
Low-D demo:=>
https://youtu.be/amhMVCjU2mg
Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Sun Apr 23, 2017 12:55 pm
by Tom Dempsey
Just don't ask him if they're available in Proto 48, he'll refuse to talk to you for the rest of the show.
Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Sun Apr 23, 2017 1:00 pm
by Rufus T. Firefly
Molybdenum grease? Seems like more than a little overkill...
Ok, just what's in that ore car and how much weight was that?
Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Sun Apr 23, 2017 1:15 pm
by Seaboard Air Line Fan
I hope the brakes work!!!
Heck, I'm happy if all the wheels touch the track at the same time and rotate when the car moves

Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Sun Apr 23, 2017 3:29 pm
by GreggL
Am I correct in reading the Youtube video description that the ore car is rolling down a a grade with 10" of height difference?? Also, the car looks to be loaded with nuts and bolts. They certainly do roll well, but am not sure what this proves, without seeing a comparison to other free rolling trucks and wheels such as Protocraft and especially the Grabowski P:48 wheelsets.
...gregg
Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Sun Apr 23, 2017 3:45 pm
by Rufus T. Firefly
GreggL wrote:Am I correct in reading the Youtube video description that the ore car is rolling down a a grade with 10" of height difference?? Also, the car looks to be loaded with nuts and bolts. They certainly do roll well, but am not sure what this proves, without seeing a comparison to other free rolling trucks and wheels such as Protocraft and especially the Grabowski P:48 wheelsets.
...gregg
Point!
Heck, even my cars with Athearn trucks and IM wheelsets start rolling off on what I thought was a level surface in my shop, not even on track,

Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Sun Apr 23, 2017 7:43 pm
by J. S. Bach
Rufus T. Firefly wrote:Heck, even my cars with Athearn trucks and IM wheelsets start rolling off on what I thought was a level surface in my shop, not even on track,

Same here; Weaver trucks/same IM wheelsets do just as well. Most of my cars will have one of those setups.
Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Mon Apr 24, 2017 1:01 am
by bob turner
It's like round boiler bellies and scale models that fit the track. Everybody has to have a hangup.
I don't have a big enough test loop for axle friction to be a factor. Fourteen cars and I am done.
Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Mon Apr 24, 2017 1:33 am
by webenda
Rufus T. Firefly wrote:GreggL wrote:Am I correct in reading the Youtube video description that the ore car is rolling down a a grade with 10" of height difference?? Also, the car looks to be loaded with nuts and bolts. They certainly do roll well, but am not sure what this proves, without seeing a comparison to other free rolling trucks and wheels such as Protocraft and especially the Grabowski P:48 wheelsets.
...gregg
Point!
Heck, even my cars with Athearn trucks and IM wheelsets start rolling off on what I thought was a level surface in my shop, not even on track,

"
Athearn Delrin trucks are the best truck in the world, except for wheel sets. The steel cone end is not good, and the wheels are wobbly. Still, they are much better than any other trucks in rolling quality. I decided to improve Athearn trucks." --Tad Daito
Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Mon Apr 24, 2017 9:40 am
by up148
Yes, he is very passionate about this conversion. He's been working on this for decades.
BH
Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Mon Apr 24, 2017 9:50 am
by Rufus T. Firefly
webenda wrote:Rufus T. Firefly wrote:GreggL wrote:Am I correct in reading the Youtube video description that the ore car is rolling down a a grade with 10" of height difference?? Also, the car looks to be loaded with nuts and bolts. They certainly do roll well, but am not sure what this proves, without seeing a comparison to other free rolling trucks and wheels such as Protocraft and especially the Grabowski P:48 wheelsets.
...gregg
Point!
Heck, even my cars with Athearn trucks and IM wheelsets start rolling off on what I thought was a level surface in my shop, not even on track,

"
Athearn Delrin trucks are the best truck in the world, except for wheel sets. The steel cone end is not good, and the wheels are wobbly. Still, they are much better than any other trucks in rolling quality. I decided to improve Athearn trucks." --Tad Daito
Easiest way to improve Athearn truck is to replace the wheels sets to IM ones. Really needs very little more than that for the vast majority of modelers.
Your chart was of Athearn Boxcars -- just because we mention Athearn trucks it does not follow that Athearn boxcars are in play. I think I only have 1 of them; my freight cars are of a wide range of sources and materials as well. What is more relevant would be the weighting of the cars and to what standards that was performed.
So back to his ore - what weight was in that? I'd have been far more impressed if he had not had to give it a goodly shove and had it just rolled off on its own. Bet I can take a hopper with my Athearn trucks, fill it with tungsten, and give it a good shove, and that it will go round and round........
Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Mon Apr 24, 2017 12:00 pm
by Roy
Frankly, it sounds as if this Low-D idea is to use needlepoint bearings, plus a low-friction bearing on one of the wheels(to allow for differential rolling on turns). Something I've been advocating for a while, too.
Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Mon Apr 24, 2017 12:05 pm
by Tom Dempsey
I read and re-read the article. I think the point he is trying to make is that our cars pick up a lot of drag going around corners with RP-25 wheels and that is why we generally need far more power than the trains should justify. His wheels are apparently engineered to reduce drag in turns which allows the train to be longer. He is very passionate about the whole thing, as I said, try to ask questions or bring up P48 and he'll just shut you down. But it is a wonderful exercise in engineering to solve a problem. As to whether the problem needed solving, that remains to be seen.
Re: May/June issue of The O Scale Resource Magazine is out
Posted: Mon Apr 24, 2017 12:53 pm
by Rufus T. Firefly