Page 1 of 1

Samuel Shaw passenger cars 1930's

Posted: Tue Apr 11, 2017 7:25 pm
by Carey Williams
Hello all

Samuel Shaw of Drexel Hill . PA a contemporary to Alexander, Egolf and Icken model modeler placing ads in the Model Maker Magazine for his passenger cars 1931-1934 . Shaw offered cars in Standard Gauge , 1/2" scale and later O scale . Has any one ever heard of Shaw? any flyers ? examples of his cars ?
I recently bought a Standard gauge passenger car that I believe is Shaw built. Construction is similar to that of a O scale car on steroids.
Car measures in at 31" dwarfing the Mini-Scale 17/64ths coach at only 22" in length .

Sheet metal sides and covered roof, wood floor and under-body detail . Trucks side frames cast brass wheels construction same as most O scale.

Thank you for your help .
Cheers Carey


Shaw    Modelmaker Dec 1931.jpg
Shaw Modelmaker Dec 1931.jpg (605.19 KiB) Viewed 7146 times


Shaw    Modelmaker Jan 1932.jpg
Shaw Modelmaker Jan 1932.jpg (638.78 KiB) Viewed 7146 times





IMG_1799.JPG
IMG_1799.JPG (2.57 MiB) Viewed 7146 times


IMG_1800.JPG
IMG_1800.JPG (1.71 MiB) Viewed 7146 times


IMG_1802.JPG
IMG_1802.JPG (2.01 MiB) Viewed 7146 times



IMG_2278.JPG
IMG_2278.JPG (1.52 MiB) Viewed 7146 times

IMG_2279.JPG
IMG_2279.JPG (1.14 MiB) Viewed 7146 times

IMG_2280.JPG
IMG_2280.JPG (1.19 MiB) Viewed 7146 times

IMG_2281.JPG
IMG_2281.JPG (1.31 MiB) Viewed 7146 times

Re: Samuel Shaw passenger cars 1930's

Posted: Tue Apr 11, 2017 9:47 pm
by rogruth
I don't know much about that period but those look really nice and seem to be well built for cars from the 1930s.

Re: Samuel Shaw passenger cars 1930's

Posted: Wed Apr 12, 2017 1:47 pm
by Nortonville Phil
I was wondering if the Roberts Lines passenger cars were related to these. Or if not were they derived from an earlier model company. They were cast aluminum I think. Also were the Shaw passenger cars built to 7/16" scale?

Re: Samuel Shaw passenger cars 1930's

Posted: Thu Apr 13, 2017 12:07 am
by Carey Williams
Hello all

Shaw built the Standard Gauge (2 1/8") to proper scale of 3/8" .

The Mini -scale coach shown in the above photo is 17/64ths ....proper scale for O gauge 1 1/4"

Randall cars are cast aluminum , first produced in the late 20's and 30's by Thomas Randall of Chicagoland ... producing a Hudson and 4 passenger cars all castings ..go build them yourself. Scaled roughly at 3/8" advertised to be used on Standard or K gauge .....any one ever hear of K gauge ?

Relic of Evanston, Il produced the Randall cars in conjunction with Thomas Randall's son in the late 70's . They continued to supply castings for the cars now 4 long (28" and 4 short 21" ) with both closed or open ends versions for Bob Thon of Roberts Lines through the 90's when the molds wore out . The engine was never recast as the mold was lost , destroyed, etc sometime in the 30's ..so very few engines were ever cast .

Park trains in 1946 got hold of a Randall Hudson and used it to recast the Hudson with a few modifications ...taking out ads in Model Railroading Oct-Dec 1946 ..... new castings for a Standard Gauge or 3/8" scale engine ..during the race to the smaller gauges ...TT gauge introduced at the same time, did not do well. A few sets of castings may have be sold only a handful remain.

Here is a link to a video of a Randall Hudson pulling 4 of the short cars built to 1 gauge .

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f3jTS6YKRxk

Below is a photo of the Shaw car compared to a large Randall 28 and a Liberty Lines ( same size as Lionel) State car 21 1/2"

Also photo of Randall with cars , relic flyer , ad for Park train , Randall Hudson compared to Mini-scale Hudson

The Randall Hudson is crude by today's standards .... but for 1929 it was way ahead of the curve . Unfortunately no flyers , ads , paper work has surfaced on Randall during the early years. He may have been part of a large standard gauge layout to be installed at the Century of Progress in Chicago . The initial builder of the layout failed to interest Lionel to sponsor it and used American Flyer as a back up . The Century of Progress was the springboard for O scale with several major railroad sponsored huge layouts seen by millions . The exposure to scale models running turned the tide of toy train world and the death call for standard gauge .

Cheers Carey

Mi-Loco also worked in 3/8" scale ..producing a Hudson and K4....... as pictured in his 1935 catalog ...photo below ..3/8" scale are the big engines ..17/64th's model the small ones...has any ever seen a Mi-Loco piece in 3 /8" ?




1st day running.JPG
1st day running.JPG (358.25 KiB) Viewed 7064 times
castings.jpg
castings.jpg (92.4 KiB) Viewed 7064 times

IMG_0258.JPG
IMG_0258.JPG (1.66 MiB) Viewed 7064 times

Re: Samuel Shaw passenger cars 1930's

Posted: Thu Apr 13, 2017 7:13 pm
by rogruth
Nice stuff!!!

Re: Samuel Shaw passenger cars 1930's

Posted: Fri Apr 14, 2017 1:24 pm
by Nortonville Phil
Carey,

Thanks for the history on Roberts lines/Randell. That answered my curiosity and I was not aware of that history. :D

Re: Samuel Shaw passenger cars 1930's

Posted: Fri Apr 14, 2017 1:32 pm
by bob turner
Blown away with your extensive knowledge. I had no idea this stuff existed.

Re: Samuel Shaw passenger cars 1930's

Posted: Sat Apr 15, 2017 12:03 am
by Carey Williams
Hello all

Thank you for your kind words . I had no idea there was a bit of a "Standard Gauge" movement within the scale world ... and it was even given a nod by early folks at Model Railroading in it's first year of publication (1934) Standard gauge 2 1/8" common 3/8" scale or 7/16" less common !

Also note the confession in O gauge that 17/64 ths is more accurate!

So as the scale model train hobby grew there were some modelers in Standard gauge ... fighting the tide to go small .

I forgot to add the MI-Loco catalog pages ( catalog was out by December 1934 ) ..note huge display of equipment available .both in O gauge ( 17/64ths only please... ) and 3/8" ....1 gauge ...
Whilst researching through MR ..I came across a want ad in 1942 ...someone was searching for Mi-Loco 3/8" pieces .. perhaps me in a former life ... they have to be out there somewhere ....

a 35" long K4 in 1 gauge ....

note "factory" photo..( small house west end of Cleveland) ...look in window ..3/8" scale Hudson ..... where is a time machine when you need one ?


Cheers Carey

Re: Samuel Shaw passenger cars 1930's

Posted: Sat Apr 15, 2017 9:05 am
by rogruth
Carey,
Good info.
Thanks.

Re: Samuel Shaw passenger cars 1930's

Posted: Sat Apr 15, 2017 12:29 pm
by ScaleCraft
Carey Williams wrote: Scaled roughly at 3/8" advertised to be used on Standard or K gauge .....any one ever hear of K gauge ?







1st day running.JPG
castings.jpg

IMG_0258.JPG

Interestingly, the writeup you scanned calls it LGB K track.
Now, having some passing familiarity with #1 gauge, and a tad with "standard" gauge, and the German outfit that re-introduced #1 gauge...but that was 1968.
So how did we end up with LGB track at the time these ads were published?

Re: Samuel Shaw passenger cars 1930's

Posted: Sat Apr 15, 2017 10:00 pm
by Nortonville Phil
Scalecraft:

That Randell passenger car add is from the late 60s' early 70s' time period. That is why they mention and picture LGB track.