Nobody can answer the question, it seems.
Did the die-cast tooling ever get changed on the NW line?
I am aware of difficulty and expense to do so.
Does anyone actually have an NW that says anything BUT General Models, Wheaton?
None of mine do.
Opinion, until we get more facts, this whole "rare, Wheaton" stuff is a construct.
Look at what they did with builder's plates on SAND-CAST BRONZE steam locos, which is far easier and less costly to change than die-cast tooling.
That OGR thread at 9 years old was useless then, useless now. Pure speculation with no facts or evidence.
All Nation
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: All Nation
Dave....gone by invitation
- ScaleCraft
- Posts: 6693
- Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm
Re: All Nation
Maroon has one with nothing....and a can motor.
If he posts the photo, you can see.
So far, all with markings are General Models, Wheaton.
Post your contrary units!
If he posts the photo, you can see.
So far, all with markings are General Models, Wheaton.
Post your contrary units!
Dave....gone by invitation
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3141
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Re: All Nation
I have six locomotives that started life as the GMC-All Nation NW2 -- Four NW2s and two SW1s (neither the half-way-there factory versions). Five of the six shells have identical markings: General Models Corp, Wheaton, Illinois, #4001. One of them, however, does not have this mark:

https://dl.dropbox.com/scl/fi/oq11g15wa9bwhecge9p55/No-Markings.jpg?rlkey=qxt584p6hvoeicf1tafwm4wxg
There is no sign of filing or grinding. The surface finish in the area where the markings usually appears to be as-cast. I would guess that at some point, after decades of selling the NW2 with the GMC mark, All Nation decided to modify the tooling to eliminate it. I would further guess that this is late in the production life, so, if anything, its not the Wheaton mark that is rare, but the absence thereof. Note that this is a data-informed guess, but it's still just a guess.
I should also mention that this unit has a Pittman can motor in it. I have not disassembled the model to inspect the chassis, which is what it would take to determine if the modification needed to mount a can motor was clean (indicating a factory job) or the work of an individual modeler. I have no evidence that All Nation ever offered any model with a Pittman can from the factory, but, then again, I haven't gone looking for such evidence.
Having said all that, if you want to talk about rare EMD switchers, let's talk about this:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/388067551953
The "Doorstop Know Prize" will be awarded to anybody who can correctly identify the manufacturer of this model. As an aside, don't those ScaleCraft passenger/express trucks look fetching?
Jim

https://dl.dropbox.com/scl/fi/oq11g15wa9bwhecge9p55/No-Markings.jpg?rlkey=qxt584p6hvoeicf1tafwm4wxg
There is no sign of filing or grinding. The surface finish in the area where the markings usually appears to be as-cast. I would guess that at some point, after decades of selling the NW2 with the GMC mark, All Nation decided to modify the tooling to eliminate it. I would further guess that this is late in the production life, so, if anything, its not the Wheaton mark that is rare, but the absence thereof. Note that this is a data-informed guess, but it's still just a guess.
I should also mention that this unit has a Pittman can motor in it. I have not disassembled the model to inspect the chassis, which is what it would take to determine if the modification needed to mount a can motor was clean (indicating a factory job) or the work of an individual modeler. I have no evidence that All Nation ever offered any model with a Pittman can from the factory, but, then again, I haven't gone looking for such evidence.
Having said all that, if you want to talk about rare EMD switchers, let's talk about this:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/388067551953
The "Doorstop Know Prize" will be awarded to anybody who can correctly identify the manufacturer of this model. As an aside, don't those ScaleCraft passenger/express trucks look fetching?
Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size
-
bob turner
- Posts: 13676
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm
Re: All Nation
I note that only three of us have contributed in the last 7 days. Have all our friends succumbed to old age and television? I admit I had a spectacular week, with the winter storms giving us not only winds gusting to 30 knots, but also a totally empty airport upon which to wreak havoc. And now it is back to drilling holes - but in the meantime, here are more All Nation photos, courtesy of my friends at Shutterfly:

Standard Atwater/All Nation. I am enamored with the brass cast versions, but still find these quite nice models. Decals are from Jim Wilhite (RIP) who did a lot of really nice decals for me. I think one of these is my 1 1/8' gauge unit, powered by a tiny heart-pump motor. I have another set in UP colors.
Standard Atwater/All Nation. I am enamored with the brass cast versions, but still find these quite nice models. Decals are from Jim Wilhite (RIP) who did a lot of really nice decals for me. I think one of these is my 1 1/8' gauge unit, powered by a tiny heart-pump motor. I have another set in UP colors.
- R.K. Maroon
- Posts: 3141
- Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2011 9:20 pm
Re: All Nation
R.K. Maroon wrote:The "Doorstop Know Prize" will be awarded to anybody who can correctly identify the manufacturer of this model. As an aside, don't those ScaleCraft passenger/express trucks look fetching?
https://dl.dropbox.com/scl/fi/lvi2q39abj90nigs7rs7f/Super-Scale-SW1_01.JPG?rlkey=v4ucyl48yna2wypj30o8u8l6e
Nortonville Phil provided the correct answer to the quiz: Super Scale

https://dl.dropbox.com/scl/fi/cj0nnchcc103s0v5zq6cq/Super-Scale-SW-1-Box.jpg?rlkey=15d18a1maf9y9ugsdvj8nliap
This copper model was offered in HO, S, and O:

https://dl.dropbox.com/scl/fi/95upxnhv2cxhsv6poxnph/Super-Scale-MR-1948-05-p373.jpg?rlkey=ap84s5oele4a6qe6tthjme1zv
As best I can tell, no trucks or drive were ever offered for the O version. The model on eBay is the only one I have seen that has been completed and powered. I have two from-the-factory shells:

https://dl.dropbox.com/scl/fi/t9v3ighnh8avzu0d85ovw/Super-Scale-EMC-600-HP-Switcher-Shell-03.jpg?rlkey=cu20egwjigbjk0v9qqikc6zru
Finishing one of these would be a neat project but, sadly, I doubt it will ever float to the top of my list.
Jim
The link below any photo will display the image full size
Re: All Nation
Bob, "I think one of these is my 1 1/8' gauge unit, powered by a tiny heart-pump motor."
I'm curious, where did you come across a tiny heart pump motor?
Dan Weinhold
I'm curious, where did you come across a tiny heart pump motor?
Dan Weinhold
Re: All Nation
Sorry, I have so little to contribute to this thread, that I just read it. But, I never realized Super Scale (never heard of them) made "S" scale kits as well as HO. Makes sense, as back in beginning very little was offered in RTR.
Right now I'm patiently waiting for the arrival of a 1 of 1, O scale Union Pacific #50 Gas Turbine. This was the first GTEL and was a double cabbed experimental locomotive and the beginning of the collaboration between GE and the UP to increase the pulling power of UP trains. Number 50 was only used for a little over a year, as it was on loan to the UP to see if it would work. The experiment was a success and the UP ordered 10 of a single cab version in the early 50's and the rest is history. Being loud, it would never work east of the Mississippi, but in the wide open spaces that the UP operated in the noise wasn't as much of an issue.
Overland Models offered a model of the #50 in HO, but no one offered them in any other scale. Tom Marsh was a bonafied UP nut, which made him a godsend to the Union Pacific model train guys in the world. T
his particular O scale model was made by a couple of Japanese craftsmen for a model railroad club in Japan. They had to have some affiliation with KTM or someone who could make the shell as it is not a typical cast construction, but made from sheet brass. I've got the names of the two craftsmen, but I'm trying to get more info such as build date and anything else I can. Like doorstops, the history of a brass model is almost as important as the model itself.
The paintwork is outstanding, the shell detail is excellent and the model is very correct on what I check against photos. Same build quality as the early OMI turbines imported back in the 80's, which was excellent. The Achilles heel of the OMI turbines was the soldering and the infamous "tank drives", but as far as detail was concerned, they were as good as anything imported.
This model is powered by "magic carpet drives" or a Japanese derivative of it, so the interior is completely open and visible through the side screens. I'm seriously thinking of adding a model of the prime mover turbine and generator, but it would be pretty much a total fabrication job, as I can't find any believable 1/48 scale models of a GE-101 Turbine engine.
For a UP turbine guy this is the holy grail of O scale turbines. It's the only O scale model I've heard of or seen in my almost 50 years of UP brass model buying. To say I'm excited is an understatement and I'm proud to be the steward of this model, even though it comes late in my model train life. I'll post some photos when it arrives.
Right now I'm patiently waiting for the arrival of a 1 of 1, O scale Union Pacific #50 Gas Turbine. This was the first GTEL and was a double cabbed experimental locomotive and the beginning of the collaboration between GE and the UP to increase the pulling power of UP trains. Number 50 was only used for a little over a year, as it was on loan to the UP to see if it would work. The experiment was a success and the UP ordered 10 of a single cab version in the early 50's and the rest is history. Being loud, it would never work east of the Mississippi, but in the wide open spaces that the UP operated in the noise wasn't as much of an issue.
Overland Models offered a model of the #50 in HO, but no one offered them in any other scale. Tom Marsh was a bonafied UP nut, which made him a godsend to the Union Pacific model train guys in the world. T
his particular O scale model was made by a couple of Japanese craftsmen for a model railroad club in Japan. They had to have some affiliation with KTM or someone who could make the shell as it is not a typical cast construction, but made from sheet brass. I've got the names of the two craftsmen, but I'm trying to get more info such as build date and anything else I can. Like doorstops, the history of a brass model is almost as important as the model itself.
The paintwork is outstanding, the shell detail is excellent and the model is very correct on what I check against photos. Same build quality as the early OMI turbines imported back in the 80's, which was excellent. The Achilles heel of the OMI turbines was the soldering and the infamous "tank drives", but as far as detail was concerned, they were as good as anything imported.
This model is powered by "magic carpet drives" or a Japanese derivative of it, so the interior is completely open and visible through the side screens. I'm seriously thinking of adding a model of the prime mover turbine and generator, but it would be pretty much a total fabrication job, as I can't find any believable 1/48 scale models of a GE-101 Turbine engine.
For a UP turbine guy this is the holy grail of O scale turbines. It's the only O scale model I've heard of or seen in my almost 50 years of UP brass model buying. To say I'm excited is an understatement and I'm proud to be the steward of this model, even though it comes late in my model train life. I'll post some photos when it arrives.
Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 61 guests