Brass Prices

Discuss All Facets of 2-Rail, 1/48 Scale, Model Railroading
E7
Posts: 8404
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 1:35 am

Re: Brass Prices

Postby E7 » Tue Jun 13, 2017 7:19 pm


bob turner
Posts: 13676
Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:57 pm

Re: Brass Prices

Postby bob turner » Tue Jun 13, 2017 8:36 pm

Bob Smith used a set of Alco drawings to come up with that PA nose. Key almost made the same mistake. Even when confronted with photo evidence, they were saying "but the drawings . . ."

The MRR PRR K4 drawings didn't fool Max Gray, but they sure got to USH. And George Trager got a whole series of PSC heavyweights stuck with an unlikely roof end curvature.

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Brass Prices

Postby ScaleCraft » Tue Jun 13, 2017 9:08 pm

bob turner wrote:Bob Smith used a set of Alco drawings to come up with that PA nose. Key almost made the same mistake. Even when confronted with photo evidence, they were saying "but the drawings . . ."

The MRR PRR K4 drawings didn't fool Max Gray, but they sure got to USH. And George Trager got a whole series of PSC heavyweights stuck with an unlikely roof end curvature.



Yup. Be very careful.
Dave....gone by invitation

E7
Posts: 8404
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 1:35 am

Re: Brass Prices

Postby E7 » Wed Jun 14, 2017 7:23 am

bob turner wrote:Bob Smith used a set of Alco drawings to come up with that PA nose. Key almost made the same mistake. Even when confronted with photo evidence, they were saying "but the drawings . . ."

The MRR PRR K4 drawings didn't fool Max Gray, but they sure got to USH. And George Trager got a whole series of PSC heavyweights stuck with an unlikely roof end curvature.


All well and good, but photos confirm the drawing, though some folks can't seem to see it. As for the heavyweight ends, I've seen you state that before, but have never seen one that appeared to be incorrect. Would be interested in seeing one next time you run across it....really.

User avatar
sarge
Posts: 5138
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 2:21 pm
Location: Dungfield Manor

Re: Brass Prices

Postby sarge » Wed Jun 14, 2017 7:43 am

Drawings are not definitive.

The erection/general arrangement drawings were no more than a key to all the detail drawings that followed in the book, the ones the model manufacturers never use. Alco in particular was notoriously inaccurate as a drawing but modellers still swear by g/a's as something to refer to. I'm sure Scott gets them as definitive from his sources. Those erection drawings were notoriously inaccurate, as Bob Smith, Athearn, and several others tried to defend, especially the carbody units. "Trust the drawings."

Then the fiasco about loco boilers drawn and dimensioned without the lagging, then faithfully copied for model drawings undersized since the drawer didn't know to add the lagging. "Trust the drawings."

Too often, builders used that excuse even to explain the obvious. Bob Weaver's FA he always defended the nose taper as " on the drawings" when its pretty obvious it was put there so the nose would release from a three facet mould rather than go to five. "Trust the drawings."

Athearn, back in the 60s, got caught out by GM accidently. They were doing then current models as fast as EMD was updating their range during the great horsepower race of the 60s, and did the SW1500 in HO to a GM general arrangement drawing. Problem was EMD redesigned the whole thing before production without telling Athearn (the cheek!) and the HO guys had a bastardised SW1200 for years over that. "Trust the drawings."

Then there was the Athearn Blomberg truck, faithfully taken off an early G/a of (if memory serves) a GP7. They made that thing for years, totally wrong in form but very clear for layout. "Trust the drawings."

You can tell me its on the drawings and the drawings are sacrosanct all day long, but as long as modellers think the G/a is anything more than a key to the detail drawings in the set and actually use them in blind faith, we'll have these discussions.

Meanwhile, dated detail drawings beat erection drawings, and photos trump any drawing. They require much more effort to interpret, so I doubt if many will ever get past it. I have put together packages for importers with chronologically keyed photos clarifying details and actually heard back that the importer decided against doing what the photos show because they actually feared the reaction from the "experts" who had pored over the g/a or some MR drawing or another.

So, no. The drawings might be a good starting point (and that can be a very weak "might" if you ignore everything after the G/a in the set), but dated photos win out.

BTW, I seem to remember going through that headlight exercise and the slant followed the nose slant (a practice carried from the FT on and the E7) until someone decided it was a needless prettyism toward the end of F7 and E8 and straightened it up just before F9 and E9. Photos will tell you, though The Drawings might not. Grin!

up148
Posts: 4796
Joined: Sat Nov 01, 2008 11:52 am

Re: Brass Prices

Postby up148 » Wed Jun 14, 2017 9:36 am

In the final analysis, in regards to the model, it's what you like best or can live with. Since the E & F noses were hand formed from sheet metal panels, the possibility of any two or group being identical is remote. My original comment had to do with the uneven transition behind the headlight shrouding where it melds into the top of the nose on the Key model, not the slant of the headlight. The slant will be a debate forever, the uneven transition is something I've never seen on a prototype unit. Fortunately this depression of sorts was corrected on later runs.

BH

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Brass Prices

Postby ScaleCraft » Wed Jun 14, 2017 12:12 pm

There was another model done...confirmed with photos....heard the story years and years ago, never able to confirm or deny...everybody circled the wagons.

Seems there was the PRC owned supplier on the Atlantic Coast of the US.....and in normal fashion, without telling anybody, the developer crew snuck off one weekend with cameras. tape measures, note pads and flashlights to a museum a bit south of their locale.

Entered the museum (again, secrecy seemed to be their "thing") and drifted over to a BL-2. Tape measures, notepads, photographs.....many hours....all the data they would ever need....and they had photographic proof....went back to the shop and designed the H0 model of a BL-2....and shipped the design off to their masters in the PRC.....product arrived..shipped...and only then did anyone realize the museum had jacked up the BL-2, dragged the Blombergs out for full rebuild...and dropped a spare set of AAR trucks under it to hold the shell up off the rails.

So...photos.
Dave....gone by invitation

E7
Posts: 8404
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 1:35 am

Re: Brass Prices

Postby E7 » Wed Jun 14, 2017 12:52 pm

sarge wrote:BTW, I seem to remember going through that headlight exercise and the slant followed the nose slant (a practice carried from the FT on and the E7) until someone decided it was a needless prettyism toward the end of F7 and E8 and straightened it up just before F9 and E9. Photos will tell you, though The Drawings might not. Grin!


From the all the photos I have seen, I would tend to agree with that. The NS executive F9 sure looks vertical to me, while it's predecessors up through F7 seem to have the tilt. The E7 in the RR museum of PA does, as I have stood there and looked at it. No alcohol had been consumed prior to viewing. :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

I have heard from a well known Importer that there are 4 variations of the F nose. Buy what you like the look of.

E7
Posts: 8404
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 1:35 am

Re: Brass Prices

Postby E7 » Wed Jun 14, 2017 1:09 pm

up148 wrote:In the final analysis, in regards to the model, it's what you like best or can live with. Since the E & F noses were hand formed from sheet metal panels, the possibility of any two or group being identical is remote. My original comment had to do with the uneven transition behind the headlight shrouding where it melds into the top of the nose on the Key model, not the slant of the headlight. The slant will be a debate forever, the uneven transition is something I've never seen on a prototype unit. Fortunately this depression of sorts was corrected on later runs. BH


I definitely agree with the bolded comment. Among the Key runs of E's and F's I favor the ones done by Samhongsa and Sam Model Tech, (Sam's reincarnation).

Bottom Line: Buy what YOU like, and look it over CAREFULLY, before you plop down your cash.

Overland's O scale effort's were not the best (opinion), but I have seen some of their later HO, that looked pretty decent (more opinion). It would be interesting to see what A-Train (Ajin's successor) would do today.

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Brass Prices

Postby ScaleCraft » Wed Jun 14, 2017 9:30 pm

To me it really doesn't matter. Woody used to fling me poo all the time about the ashcan headlights on my ScaleCraft steamers. I don't care. That's the way they came.
All the striving for perfection, and all the money spent, and they still aren't perfect..and we can worry about it..or run them and enjoy them.
Dave....gone by invitation

Carey Williams
Posts: 690
Joined: Sat Dec 24, 2016 3:10 pm

Re: Brass Prices

Postby Carey Williams » Thu Jun 15, 2017 2:51 am

As Dave eloquently wrote

All the striving for perfection, and all the money spent, and they still aren't perfect..and we can worry about it..or run them and enjoy them.

Perfection , dip or no dip

As the whole world forgotten the gauge is wrong for the scale ?

Long live 17/64ths!

Scale -Craft just would look wrong if it did not have a 55 gallon drum for a headlight ... It adds a certain panache

Reality is not for everyone
I like my steam engines with cat whiskers
Cheers Carey

up148
Posts: 4796
Joined: Sat Nov 01, 2008 11:52 am

Re: Brass Prices

Postby up148 » Thu Jun 15, 2017 9:04 am

Perfection , dip or no dip. Has the whole world forgotten the gauge is wrong for the scale ?


I agree these are models and they are the wrong gauge and there are no perfect models in either plastic or brass. But, you can't see the out of gauge just looking at the model (opinion), but that dip in the nose is so prominent you see it every time you look at the model.

Sort of like winning a date with the best looking girl in high school for the homecoming dance and she shows up at that door with a boil on her forehead the size of a nickel. :shock: :shock: :shock: :shock: Just ruins the wait and anticipation. :D :D :D :D

BH

User avatar
ScaleCraft
Posts: 6693
Joined: Thu Jan 26, 2012 10:15 pm

Re: Brass Prices

Postby ScaleCraft » Thu Jun 15, 2017 11:58 am

Carey Williams wrote:
Scale -Craft just would look wrong if it did not have a 55 gallon drum for a headlight ... It adds a certain panache


Cheers Carey


Exactly. I have resisted all attempts by others to "upgrade" my engines.
Dave....gone by invitation

Tom Dempsey
Posts: 1002
Joined: Mon Dec 23, 2013 10:15 pm

Re: Brass Prices

Postby Tom Dempsey » Thu Jun 15, 2017 1:10 pm

up148 wrote:Sort of like winning a date with the best looking girl in high school for the homecoming dance and she shows up at that door with a boil on her forehead the size of a nickel. Just ruins the wait and anticipation.

BH


My memories of high school are somewhat hazy, but, I don't remember fixating on the girls foreheads.

User avatar
rex desilets
Posts: 1786
Joined: Sun Jul 15, 2007 2:18 pm

Re: Brass Prices

Postby rex desilets » Thu Jun 15, 2017 4:12 pm

Tom Dempsey wrote:
up148 wrote:Sort of like winning a date with the best looking girl in high school for the homecoming dance and she shows up at that door with a boil on her forehead the size of a nickel. Just ruins the wait and anticipation.

BH


My memories of high school are somewhat hazy, but, I don't remember fixating on the girls foreheads.
I suppose it depends on what her other *features* were :mrgreen: :mrgreen: :mrgreen: :mrgreen: :mrgreen: :mrgreen:
“Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.” – John Adams


Return to “O-Gauge, 2-Rail, Model Railroading”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 45 guests